DailyFinance Toolbar

Lou Dobbs: Can he take lessons from a reformed racist to win a Senate seat?

Posted 11:20 AM 11/25/09 ,
Print Text Size A A A
Lou Dobbs is mad as hell, and he's not going to take it anymore. And now that he's left his bully pulpit at CNN, he's hoping the masses will join him with their pitchforks and torches.

Dobbs wants to challenge Sen. Robert Menendez, a New Jersey Democrat, as a third-party candidate for the U.S. Senate in 2012, according to The Wall Street Journal. (He also may run for president, naturally.) Dobbs told reporters that he is "ruling nothing out."


Yes, the world is Dobbs's oyster. But first, he'll have to convince New Jersey Latinos that he's not actually a frothing-at-the-mouth racist, despite his years of incendiary commentary against illegal immigration.

It's a difficult task, but it's not impossible. In the 1960s, Alabama Gov. George Wallace gained national fame with his battle-cry -- "Segregation now! Segregation tomorrow! Segregation forever!" -- but renounced that view after becoming a born-again Christian. Wallace, who survived a 1972 assassination attempt, later appointed record numbers of African-Americans to positions in his administration and championed voting rights. Of course, not everyone forgave Wallace -- who, like Dobbs, was viewed as a leading political populist -- but many did.

I have no idea whether Dobbs is racist. He has said he is not, of course, but he has certainly fanned the flames of racial intolerance over the years. And now he's taking a page from the Wallace playbook, reaching out to the group he's provoked the most. "Mr. Dobbs told Spanish-language network Telemundo he now supports a plan to legalize millions of undocumented workers, a stance he long lambasted as an unfair 'amnesty,'" the Journal noted.

That's a start, but it's not enough. For Dobbs to stand a chance in a Senate election to represent New Jersey, he'll have to follow the Wallace model and apologize -- clearly and ungrudingly. The Alabama governor repeatedly told the world that his segregationist views were wrong. And Sen. Menendez, a Cuban-American -- the sole Latino in the U.S. Senate -- would make mincemeat of Dobbs in any campaign, particularly if Dobbs ran as a third-party candidate. Both Democrats and Republicans would have a field day. Over the years, Dobbs has generated loads of CNN-produced fodder for 30-second TV spots, including his specious claim that illegal immigrants were responsible for a spike in cases of leprosy. Several months ago, Dobbs notified police that he'd found gunshots fired at his house.

But Dobbs may find a willing audience in New Jersey. Populist rage over high taxes and corruption led voters in this blue state to oust incumbent Gov. Jon Corzine, a Democrat, in favor of Republican challenger Chris Christie. (I'm a liberal New Jersey Democrat -- I volunteered for Barack Obama's presidential campaign -- but to the shock of my friends and family, I supported Christie.)

If the 2012 election were held tomorrow, Menendez might be worried. But his race is years away. Passions can cool, or even change. But that also gives Dobbs some time to mend fences. And if he hopes to get elected to so much as dogcatcher, he's got plenty of fences to mend.
Jonathan Berr

Jonathan Berr

View all Articles »
Financial Writer and Media Columnist

Jonathan Berr is a former reporter with Bloomberg News whose work has appeared in The New York Times, BusinessWeek and The Philadelphia Inquirer. In 2000, he won the Gerald Loeb Award, one of the most prestigious prizes in business journalism.

Read More
SUBSCRIBE TO:
RSS
COMMENTS ( 2 )
Page 1 of 1 1
MattoleBoy
1:34AM Jan 8 2010 
Typical and perdictable when a journalist or others don't like it when citizens complain about illegals being here the journalist and or their friends use the race card, your a racist if you don not want illegals invading our homeland.
Let's see what does Jonathan Berr not understand about the word illegal.
He is the complete moron and a follow the herd political correct non thinker.
Most Americans dont want illegals here and that's that ,how about majority rules, Mr. idiot Jonathan Berr
Are we all racist because we don't want the the problems, gangs crime, overcrowded schools overtaxed hospitals that pass on the losses to middle class americans ,driving down wages for construction etc.
and on and on and on we have to deal with it ?
typical and perdictable when a journalist or others dont like it when citizens complain about illegals being here the journalist and or their friends use the race card, your a racist if you don not want illegals invading our homeland.
Lets seee what does Jonathan Berr bot understand aobut teh word illegal. its he who is the complete moron and a follow the herd political correct non thinker.
Most Americans dont want illegals here and thats that ,how about majority rules, Mr. idiot elite Jonathan Berr
Oh ok were racist if we complain so you win the argument right by overplaying your favorite race card

Mr.elite Jonathan Berr only the rich and elite truly benefit from exploiting them.
  Reply Rate This Comment
(0 RATINGS)
MattoleBoy
1:34AM Jan 8 2010 
Typical and perdictable when a journalist or others don't like it when citizens complain about illegals being here the journalist and or their friends use the race card, your a racist if you don not want illegals invading our homeland.
Let's see what does Jonathan Berr not understand about the word illegal.
He is the complete moron and a follow the herd political correct non thinker.
Most Americans dont want illegals here and that's that ,how about majority rules, Mr. idiot Jonathan Berr
Are we all racist because we don't want the the problems, gangs crime, overcrowded schools overtaxed hospitals that pass on the losses to middle class americans ,driving down wages for construction etc.
and on and on and on we have to deal with it ?
typical and perdictable when a journalist or others dont like it when citizens complain about illegals being here the journalist and or their friends use the race card, your a racist if you don not want illegals invading our homeland.
Lets seee what does Jonathan Berr bot understand aobut teh word illegal. its he who is the complete moron and a follow the herd political correct non thinker.
Most Americans dont want illegals here and thats that ,how about majority rules, Mr. idiot elite Jonathan Berr
Oh ok were racist if we complain so you win the argument right by overplaying your favorite race card

Mr.elite Jonathan Berr only the rich and elite truly benefit from exploiting them.
  Reply Rate This Comment
(0 RATINGS)
Page 1 of 1 1
GOT SOMETHING TO SAY?
YOU'LL BE ASKED TO REGISTER OR SIGN IN BEFORE POSTING A COMMENT.
Make a Comment
Comment
 
Follow Us
Follow Our Writers
Pallavi Gogoi Pallavi Gogoi Financial Writer
Peter Cohan Peter Cohan Financial Columnist
Sarah Gilbert Sarah Gilbert Features Writer
Gene Marcial Gene Marcial Financial Columnist
Jeff Bercovici Jeff Bercovici Media Columnist
James Altucher James Altucher Financial Columnist
Mercedes M. Cardona Mercedes M. Cardona Retail Reporter
Nikhil Hutheesing Nikhil Hutheesing Assistant Managing Editor
Latif Lewis Latif Lewis Business News Editor
More Writers

Headlines From DailyFinance Partners

CNN Money
CNBC
Smart Money
Fox Business
Engadget
BloggingStocks
 WalletPop
AOL Small Business
Luxist
Housing Watch
AOL News
Business NewsInvesting and Real EstatePersonal Finance at WalletPopSmall Business

Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Trademarks | HELP

© 2009 AOL Inc. All Rights Reserved