Over the past few weeks, we've received dozens of emails from readers identifying themselves as former J.C. Penney (JCP) customers. And the vast majority of them said its new apparel offerings were the biggest reason they've stopped shopping there.
"I have been a customer of JCP for over 20 years. The only reason I still go there is because of the salon," writes Jacqueline Price. "I do not buy any merchandise in this store since they did away with all the lines I loved, such as St John's Bay [and] Gloria Vanderbilt."
Another reader, Kris Christensen, echoes the sentiment that the retailer is ditching the clothes she loves in favor of new collections that don't appeal to her.
"J.C. Penney was the last store to sell clothes for women that were reasonably priced and well made," writes Christensen. "If emptying out the stores of decent clothing and stocking them with the cheapest made rags possible is the great change he was talking about, he's finding out he was wrong."
We're guessing Johnson would bristle at the suggestion that J.C. Penney's new apparel collections are "the cheapest made rags possible." If anything, he's attempted to upscale the retailer by bringing in well-known brands like Martha Stewart Living and by dedicating floorspace to boutiques featuring the likes of Levi's and Izod.
But those fashion-forward brands apparently don't appeal to the disgruntled shoppers who wrote to us.
An Elderly Exodus
Interestingly, most of the readers who emailed DailyFinance are older; and these customers feel the new J.C. Penney is abandoning their demographic.
"Penney's is trying to attract a younger, hipper customer, but frankly its loyal customer base is older, heading into elderly," writes Katherine Troyer. "The company has dropped many of the brands and clothing styles favored by older people on a budget."
Another reader identified herself as a senior citizen and bemoaned that J.C. Penney "threw their loyal, mostly older customers out."
Yet another ex-customer wrote in to complain that the retailer is now dominated by "edgy styles only a 16-year-old can wear." She added that she'd taken her business to Sears (SHLD) and Kohl's (KSS).
A Critical Darling, a Popular Failure
We did get a few favorable opinions on the new apparel.
"I'm 56 and love the clothes," writes Meredith Porterfield. "They are hip, edgy and very affordable."
Meanwhile, the new direction has also met with approval in fashion-forward circles: Both Esquire and GQ gave positive coverage to the arrival of style icon Nick Wooster as new head of menswear.
And on a personal note, I checked out my local J.C. Penney recently and found that for the first time in my life, it looks like a store where I'd actually go shopping. The Levi's boutique presented an attractive array of denim choices, and I was impressed by the new shirts and ties from Stafford.
Menswear site Dappered recently used an interesting analogy to make this very point, floating the hypothetical situation of Miller ditching its usual beer in favor of IPAs and stouts brewed by world-renowned craft brewers.
In this hypothetical example, the loyal Miller fans would leave in droves, offended by the fancy new beer and by the suggestion that the beer they used to love was low-quality swill. And no matter how many new drinkers Miller gained from the switch, it wouldn't be enough to offset the loss of their former customer base.
"Meanwhile, there's a slight uptick in new customers giving the reworked line of beers a try ... but it's scattered support," writes the author. "Most of these potential customers already have allegiances to other breweries."
In trying to transform J.C. Penney into the Apple Store of apparel, Johnson has undoubtedly won over some new shoppers. But he apparently didn't realize how many of his established customers he would lose in the process.
In his latest earnings call, Johnson acknowledged that his radical new pricing strategy was a "big mistake," and he's already brought back sales and coupons. But a coupon isn't enough to get people to buy clothes they don't want.
Christine White tells us that she stopped going to J.C. Penney because she wasn't impressed by its new merchandise, but that she decided to give it another chance this past weekend after getting a couple of coupons online.
"I went there again on Saturday. I had received two Internet coupons and decided to try and find something," she tells us. "After about 45 minutes, I was only able to use one of the coupons because I couldn't find anything I liked enough to spend money on."
Matt Brownell is the consumer and retail reporter for DailyFinance. You can reach him at Matt.Brownell@teamaol.com, and follow him on Twitter at @Brownellorama.