Caveat Investor: SEC Says Hedge Funds Can Advertise to Everyone

Getty Images
Who wants to invest like a millionaire?

Lots of people, potentially, which is why SEC commissioner Luis Aguilar voted on Wednesday against a rule that will allow hedge funds and other companies looking for private investments to advertise to the general public. The change, Aguilar said, "will make fraud easier by allowing fraudsters to cast a wider net for victims."

Aguilar was the lone commissioner to vote no; the measure passed 4-1, lifting an 80-year-old restriction intended to prevent ordinary investors from being persuaded to take risks with their money that they can't afford.

Since the private offerings of hedge funds and startups seeking investments are exempt from public financial reporting requirements, these opportunities are restricted to wealthy investors -- those with at least $1 million in assets in addition to their primary residence, or an annual income of $200,000 (or $300,000 with a spouse) for the previous two years. (About 7.4 percent of U.S. households have a net worth of $1 million or more, the AP reports.) Such high-net-worth individuals are thought to be better able to handle the risk of more opaque and aggressive investments, and currently they're the only ones that issuers of private stock are allowed to solicit.

By October, that restriction will lift, enabling hedge funds and others to spread the word about their offerings however they like. But the rule about about who can invest in such companies will remain the same. And since the responsibility for vetting investors falls on hedge funds themselves, it's possible that far-reaching ads in print and online, or high-pressure sales tactics, could be used by mini-Madoffs to ensnare less savvy investors in fraudulent schemes. This has been Aguilar's concern, "a sentiment echoed by many investor advocates Wednesday," The Washington Post reports.

The change was mandated by the Jumpstart Our Business Startups (JOBS) Act of 2012, a bipartisan attempt to promote small business funding by loosening certain securities regulations. The SEC missed Congress's deadline to approve the regulation by more than a year; according to Bloomberg, Chairman Mary Jo White mentioned both the law and the timing as factors compelling the commission to approve the new rule now, despite concerns like Aguilar's:

"Given the explicit language of the JOBS Act as well as the statutory deadline which passed last July, the commission should act without any further delay. This does not mean, however, that the commission should not take steps to pursue additional investor safeguards if and where such measures become needed."

It seems that such steps might be rather modest: according to the AP, "the SEC proposed to monitor the advertising and collect data on how it affects the market for private securities offerings." This was good enough for Aguilar's fellow Democratic commissioner Elisse B. Walter, who voted in favor.

Advocates of the new rule say the old advertising restriction was badly outdated, having been enacted during the Great Depression, and caused many investors to miss opportunities. One businessman involved in the private share marketplace told Bloomberg that "the SEC has today showed its commitment to democratizing the investing process and putting an end to yesterday's 'old boy' investor networks."

But those without a financial interest in increased private stock ownership have been more critical. In October, Bloomberg reports, an SEC advisory committee recommended that the proposed rule be written to include new investor protections, which did not happen. Specifically, the committee suggested revising the definition of "accredited investor" in order to reduce the number of people eligible to invest. And the North American Securities Administrators Association protested the SEC's proposed lifting of the ad ban after it was presented for public comment in August. According to state regulators, private offers were the leading cause of enforcement actions in 2011.

Wednesday's news was greeted with widespread derision on Twitter, as the trending hashtag #hedgefundslogans quickly became a vehicle for jokes about high fees, low returns, and carried-interest compensation. And Bloomberg Businessweek's July 11 cover story, "Hedge Funds Are for Suckers," comes with an illustration that has to be seen to be believed: a visual pun that turns "performance" into a double entendre, impugning the manhood of fund managers. As Dealbreaker's Matt Levine observes, with a cover like that, BBW seems unlikely to see much of the upcoming hedge fund advertising action.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

What is Short Selling?

Make a profit when stocks prices fall.

View Course »

Introduction to Value Investing

Are you the next Warren Buffett?

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:
Donald Cannes

Dear Sir/Madam
Are you a business man or woman? Are you having financial distress or you want to fulfill that dream of yours and you

need fund? Are you having difficulties in obtaining a loan from hard lenders or banks because of their high loan

fees/requirements? Do you need a loan for any legitimate reason?

Then worry no more as the' Thomas Loan Company" has come to offer loans to interested applicants both locally and

overseas no matter the s*x or location but age must be 18 years and above. We offer

loans ranging from $10,000.00 (Ten Thousand United States Dollars to $50,000,000.00 (Fifty Million United States

Dollars) on a 3% interest rate, under a collateral or non-collateral loan process which can either be on a short or

long term loan depending on the applicant choice.

we offer personal loans, debt consolidation loans, venture capital, business loans, student loans, home loans or loans

for any legitimate reason.

For further enquirers and to apply for a loan from us, please feel free to contact our application desk via this

email: (OR)

Thoms Clerk Loan Company (CEO)

March 03 2014 at 4:13 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Cheryl Zhang

Liz Claman has called Edgar Perez THE expert on HFT and Knight Capital. Did you read his new book, Knightmare on Wall Street? The information is here:

September 10 2013 at 12:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

What exactly or how does hedge funds work? I know that they are complicated investments. I mean why do we have hedge funds all along? Does wealthy investors use hedge funds to minimize risks by making it more complicating for the adverarsies ? Wall Street is never a big group of same thinking investors. They are busy around the clock trying to steal from eachother and the one who is the quickest get the most money! They employ computers to scan and detect and make investments in blinding fast speeds in hope of beating everyones\' own computers themselves. They write programs and change commands every so often . Computers scan everybody[s accounts including yours in live time and take advantage of you. Computers can be instructed to avoid or sell what you buy or sell to distort your investment objectives.. It doesnt matter if it is the hedge fund or your very own brokerage house themselves. Your broker in real flesh or online are just lowly pawns.. working for the big trading firms shoving money in the blazing bonfire of Wall Street! your money get burned !

July 13 2013 at 4:40 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply