The most magnetic headline of the report was that McDonald's (MCD) burgers ranked dead last among the 21 largest burger flippers in the country. However, Yum! Brands (YUM) -- the parent company of KFC, Pizza Hut and Taco Bell -- got a double dose of bad news when KFC ranked eighth and worst on the list for chicken, and Taco Bell stumbled into a last-place eighth out of eight competitors in the burrito category.
The Fine Cuisine-Cost Conundrum
It's not necessarily ironic that the country's largest burger, fried chicken and Mexican chains ranked last in the Consumer Reports taste test. It makes sense. These chains tend to offer cheaper fare than their rivals, and part of that is a byproduct of lower spending on ingredients. Despite the advantages of buying in massive bulk, one should never expect the raw materials that go into a $1.49 Beefy 5-Layer Burrito at Taco Bell to be in the same category as those that go into a $6 burrito at Chipotle Mexican Grill (CMG).
There's also something to be said about the old adage that familiarity breeds contempt. The well-known top dogs will always be the easiest targets.
However, Taco Bell still needs to be careful. It used to be a compliment to be mentioned in the same breath as McDonald's, but these days, it's disparaging.
People Still Want Their Gorditas
Taco Bell can point to recent performance to prove that it's not being shunned by diners (relatively speaking) in the same way that McDonald's is. Outside of an unusual dip in its most recent quarter, Taco Bell has mustered positive comparable store sales pretty consistently in this country over the past couple of years. That hasn't been the case for McDonald's, which is coming off of three consecutive quarters of negative comps in the U.S.
Taco Bell should be able to turn things around for the quarter that ended in June. We'll find out how it held up later this month when Yum! Brands offers up fresh financials, but the late March arrival of the Waffle Taco and June's addition of the Quesarito likely resulted in a healthy uptick in traffic.
However, before we start thinking that recent innovations will help improve the reputation of its burritos, let's consider that the greatest innovation to hit Taco Bell in years happened two years ago -- and it didn't improve consumer perception of quality. Doritos Locos Tacos paired up Taco Bell's signature taco in a shell with a dusting of Doritos flavoring. Taco Bell has sold 825 million of them.
The Price of Popularity
If Taco Bell wants to upgrade its image, it will mean paying the price of upgrading its ingredients -- and that may not actually benefit the chain if it translates into higher prices for its meals that consumers don't want to pay.
Yes, Taco Bell ranked dead last in the survey. It may want to embrace that position, because the steps it would have to take to correct those perceptions could cost it more than it has to gain.
Motley Fool contributor Rick Munarriz has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Chipotle Mexican Grill and McDonald's. The Motley Fool owns shares of Chipotle Mexican Grill. Try any of our newsletter services free for 30 days.