Walmart's Made in USA push exposes strains of manufacturing rebirth
Matt Rourke/AP
By James B. Kelleher

When Walmart Stores (WMT) pledged last year to buy an extra $250 billion in U.S.-made goods over the next decade, it appeared to be just what was needed to help move America's putative manufacturing renaissance from rhetoric to reality.

But suppliers trying to reshore production as part of the initiative by the world's largest retailer are running into practical problems as they try to restart long-idled corners of U.S. manufacturing.

Companies that make the leap have to grapple with a host of challenges, including a shallow pool of component suppliers, an inexperienced workforce, and other shortcomings that developed during the country's long industrial decline.

"A lot of the tribal knowledge and skill sets are gone because the humans who used to do that work have either retired or died," says H. Kim Kelley, the CEO of Hampton Products International, a privately held maker of locks, lighting and other household hardware. The Foothill Ranch, California-based company began selling products made in Asia to Walmart in the 1990s and is now supplying it with some U.S.-made products.

Trying to rebuild that manufacturing capability, while making products that meet Walmart's standards, can require companies to "start from scratch," Kelley says.

Cindi Marsiglio, the Walmart vice president overseeing the U.S. sourcing push, says the retailer and its existing suppliers have 150 active reshoring projects in various stages of development. For all too many, she says, finding U.S.-made component parts has emerged as a vexing problem.

Hampton, which also makes tow straps, tie-downs and bungee cords for the automotive market, had a hard time locating a U.S. maker of lightweight but strong polyester yarn. Marsiglio says other suppliers complain of difficulty finding small motors, as well as plastic injection molding equipment and computerized cut-and-sew tools.

The issue is so widespread that Walmart is making it the focus of a two-day summit it is hosting in August in Denver. At a similar summit held in Orlando last year, Walmart focused on connecting suppliers with economic development officers from states hoping to lure the new factories.

The retailer says it is especially interested in having factory owners with excess capacity attend the August event -- even those that aren't interested in supplying Walmart directly. The hope is that they can become contract manufacturers to Walmart suppliers looking to produce in the United States.

On July 8, it is also inviting hundreds of potential vendors to an "open call" to pitch U.S.-made products to the retailer in Bentonville, Arkansas, where it is based.

Shut Plants

Walmart's critics say the company bears some responsibility for the diminished capability of U.S. manufacturers. For years, its relentless insistence that suppliers cut costs prompted companies to shut domestic plants and shift production to low-wage countries.

Now, the retailer is asking companies to come back home -- though they need little prompting. The forces pulling production back to the United States are powerful and real and include lower domestic energy prices, increasingly competitive wage rates, the benefits of greater automation, and a renewed appreciation for the value of being able to respond quickly to shifting U.S. customer demands.

Still, starting up a manufacturing operation is a complex undertaking, especially for vendors like Hampton and Redman & Associates, an Arkansas-based toymaker.

Last year, Redman sold 1.1 million battery-powered ride-on toys, such as large toy cars, in the United States -- every one of them made in Chinese contract plants. By 2016, the privately held company plans to be producing about 600,000 of those toys each year out of a brand-new company-owned and run plant in the U.S.

Mel Redman, the company's CEO and chairman, says the transition has required the company to reverse engineer everything its Chinese contractors were doing -- an exercise that wasn't easy given his executive team's background in retail.

"We didn't know much about manufacturing -- we didn't know anything about it really," he says.

Shipping Costs

Walmart declines to say how many products it has introduced as a result of the 18-month-old Made in USA initiative. But the company says consumers can now buy everything from U.S.-made flat-screen TVs, light bulbs and towels and curtains in its stores and on its website.

The flat-screen TVs, made in Winnsboro, South Carolina, by Element Electronics, may be the campaign's biggest surprise to date.

Founded in 2007, Element had until this year made all its TVs in Asia -- but it was unable to get them on Walmart's shelves because there was nothing that differentiated them from rivals' products, says CEO Mike O'Shaughnessy.

"So we began to think about what we could do differently. Well, one of the things we could do differently is to make our TVs at home," he says.

Element built a small test plant in Michigan that began producing flat-screen TVs shortly before Walmart announced the Made in USA push in January 2013. The announcement prompted the company to fast-track its expansion. Today, Element's 315,000-square-foot plant in South Carolina has six assembly lines making 32- and 40-inch TVs that are now available in all of Walmart's more than 4,000 U.S. stores.

The switch has led to significant savings in ocean freight charges and customs duties on finished goods -- though like so many companies involved in the initiative Element has had difficulty finding domestic suppliers. "We import the vast majority of our parts," says O'Shaughnessy. "Longer term, the more success we have procuring our parts domestically, the better off we expect to be."

Although Walmart has given itself 10 years to meet its $250 billion goal, Marsiglio says the retailer hopes to meet the target ahead of schedule. She says the point of the "open call" next month is to simplify a product pitching process that can challenge even long-time suppliers.

But while the door is open, the bar is high and Walmart will require any applicants to open their financial books as part of the screening process.

Given Walmart's reputation as a tough negotiator with suppliers, the disclosure of sensitive financial information to the retailer requires a leap of faith. But Element's O'Shaughnessy said his company had no misgivings about opening its books. Walmart needs to know it can rely on its vendors, he said.

"What does it cost to produce product? What does it cost to move product? Every one of the variables that make up the cost of the product we [shared] with Walmart," he says.

For stories of companies still making great products here in the USA, check out the This Built America series.


Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Forex for Beginners

Learn about trading currencies and foreign exchange transactions

View Course »

What is Short Selling?

Make a profit when stocks prices fall.

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

105 Comments

Filter by:
alfrankenfool

Meanwhile, the aisles are packed with Liberals slobbering over ship loads of cheap Chinese imports.

June 05 2014 at 10:01 AM Report abuse -3 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to alfrankenfool's comment
jojosdixoutcider

Yea that is right. A Con supported company that only caters to liberals. Where do the Cons shop? Please tell we all want to know.

June 05 2014 at 11:28 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
jeslats

wally world is still A CHINESE department. How many hugh transports bring chinese crap here daily

June 05 2014 at 5:18 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
georgettec28

Now doesn't everyone feel sorry for these poor companies who have to start from scratch?

June 05 2014 at 5:09 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
mkwrblwsk

Does that mean know Walmart will treat people like humans?

June 05 2014 at 3:47 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
mouse

WalMart's founder stocked "made in the USA" a priority, his sons made his motto a joke. They almost single handedly drove the USA manufacturers out of business here by demanding cheaply made goods. Boo Hoo. I never shop there

June 05 2014 at 2:47 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
ga7smi

pretty hard to sell american when very little of anything is made in Ameica - thank the great leader Ronald Regan for this situation

June 05 2014 at 2:08 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to ga7smi's comment
dopey.obamite

Reagan? What did Reaga sign?

June 05 2014 at 2:54 AM Report abuse -3 rate up rate down Reply
mac2jr

"If they weren't giving American consumers the products and prices they want, they would cease to exist"

WRONG.... In many areas of the country there were hundreds of small Mom and Pop stores supplying goods to the locals, but when WallyMart moved in, each was driven out of business, and thus there now is NO WHERE ELSE to shop within driving distance, much less walking distance.

Check Wilcox, Benson, Vail, South Tucson, and other towns in Arizona for an example.

June 05 2014 at 1:56 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
2 replies to mac2jr's comment
ga7smi

you are nuts

June 05 2014 at 2:09 AM Report abuse -3 rate up rate down Reply
dopey.obamite

So walmart rounded up the customers, shackled them and forced them to shop there?

June 05 2014 at 2:55 AM Report abuse -2 rate up rate down Reply
Carolyn

I agree with the person who stated that they liked an item and was going to buy several of them and then discovered that they were made not only in China, but in several other countries too.

I have found that out to be true myself, especially at - Kohl's, Target, Sears, QVC, etc., etc., and most other retailers too. I suspect that Kohl's is just an outlet for China goods. I visited four (4) different & separate departments and all their items (products) were made out of the country. I will never cross the threshold of Kohl's again, and that probably includes Target, too.

Now, as far as unions are concerned, they seemed to have outlived their usefulness. They were fine in the olden days, but these days, the public seem to speak louder than yesteryear.

Teacher unions are the very best example of their ineffectiveness, but that's entirely another story. Not for here ~

June 05 2014 at 1:27 AM Report abuse -3 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Carolyn's comment
dopey.obamite

We spend more per pupil than any developed nation.

June 05 2014 at 2:56 AM Report abuse -4 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to dopey.obamite's comment
jojosdixoutcider

Obviously before your time.

June 05 2014 at 11:30 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down
Karen

It's about damn time; especially since Walmart is a BIG reason our economy went down the tubes.

Sending our jobs, production companies, our MONEY overseas just to make themselves a dollar.

Because of WALMART and others like them, our landfills are now full of Chinese junk and polluting our soil with toxins from the JUNK they make.

No "pat on the back" for you walmart; you are directly responsible for the recession and forcing your employees onto the public welfare system to once again, save your lousy selves a couple of dollars.

Walmart sucks.

June 05 2014 at 12:14 AM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply
ezspin42

I wish they had suppliers that would provide fitted dress shirts. All they seem to have are full cut or "gentlemen's" cut , whatever that is. They both hang like horse blankets on me

June 05 2014 at 12:05 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply