10 Things Consumers Don't Understand About Credit Scores

Credit card experts debunk common misconceptions about credit scores.

Approved Credit Score.
Getty Images
By Stephanie Steinberg

ST. LOUIS -- Three numbers can affect everything from securing a mortgage or loan to how much interest you'll pay when you're approved for a house. And while they're just three numbers -- that typically range from 300 (very bad) to 850 (very good) -- there's a lot of information and regulations behind them. But don't worry, if a thing or two about your credit score has left you scratching your head, you're not alone.

"Consumers look at their credit report and they're like, 'I don't understand it. I don't know what it means,' " says Gerri Detweiler, director of consumer education for credit.com and host of Talk Credit Radio.

To clear up the confusion, several credit experts spoke at FinCon, a financial conference in St. Louis last week, and debunked misconceptions about credit scores. Here are 10 common things consumers tend to get wrong about their scores.

1. The credit bureaus Experian, TransUnion and Equifax evaluate my credit score. The three bureaus generate credit reports, but they have nothing to do with judging your credit score or advising lenders whether to approve or deny an application. "The credit report does not rate your credit," says Maxine Sweet, Experian's vice president of public education. "It simply lays out the facts of your history." So who determines what your credit score means? Companies such as FICO and VantageScore Solutions evaluate your credit risk level -- what lenders use to decide how risky it is to give you a loan -- based on your credit report. Separate scoring models have been developed to help businesses predict if a consumer will make payments as agreed, and the credit score is just one factor used in the model.

2. There's only one type of credit score. There are actually many different scores. For example, FICO has several models with varying score ranges. "If you get your FICO score from one lender, that very likely won't be the same score that you would get from another lender, even though they're using the FICO model," Sweet says. Consumers shouldn't focus on the number, she adds. Instead, look at where your score falls on the risk model and what influences that risk. If a lender declines your application or charges you a higher fee because of your risk, it will disclose factors that are negatively impacting your risk, Sweet explains. "Those factors will tell you what behavior you will need to change to change your credit history," she says.

3. When I close a credit card, the age of the card is no longer factored into my credit score. The only way you lose the benefit of a card's age is if a bureau removes the account from a credit report, says John Ulzheimer, credit expert at CreditSesame.com. "As long as it's still on a credit report, the credit scoring system still sees it, still sees how old it is and still considers the age in the scoring metric," he says. Take Ulzheimer's father as an example: He uses a Sear's credit card he opened in 1976, which is the oldest account on his credit report. "The assumption is if he were to close that card, he would lose that decades-long history of that card and potentially lower his score. That's not true," Ulzheimer says. However, there is one caveat: The score would be lost after 10 years (see No. 4).

4. A credit card stops aging the day I close it. Even when you close an account, the credit card still ages. For instance, if you close an American Express card today, the card will be one year older a year from now. And as explained above, you won't lose the value of the card's age. "Not only does it still count in your score, but it continues to age," Ulzheimer says. However, a closed account will not remain on your credit report forever. The credit bureaus delete them from credit reports after 10 years, according to Sweet. There's just one exception: "If the account is in a negative status, it will be deleted at seven years because we can only report negative account history for seven years," she says.

5. I need to carry debt to build credit. To debunk this, Detweiler points to her friend who went through a divorce and lost his home in the process. He wanted to rebuild his credit so he got a secured credit card with a $500 limit.
According to Detweiler, he only made the minimum payments because he thought it was good for his credit score to have debt. In reality, he hurt his credit by maxing out the card and carrying debt. As Detweiler says, her friend made a big mistake. "You can pay your balances in full and still build good credit," she says.

6. Medical debt is treated differently on credit reports. Credit bureaus do not discriminate when it comes to medical payments. Typically, medical bills are not reported to a bureau unless the bills are sent to a collection agency. When that happens, "medical collections are the same as any other collections," Detweiler says. "They are a serious negative. The more recent they are, the more it affects your score."

7. A credit repair company can only remove inaccuracies to improve my score. While it's true credit repair companies help you get inaccurate information corrected on your credit report, they can sometimes go one step further. "The real core competency of a credit repair company is to get stuff that's negative removed from your credit report -- whether it's accurate or inaccurate," Ulzheimer says.

8. So that means a credit repair company takes illegal action to fix my score. No, what they do is perfectly legal as long as they follow a federal statute called the Credit Repair Organizations Act. Every state has its own version of CROA. "It is a law filled with teeth," Ulzheimer says. For one, companies must disclose that they're going to take actions you could technically do yourself (at no cost), and they can't charge you until after the services have been rendered. They also can't guarantee anything, Ulzheimer says. "If they say, 'I can have that bankruptcy deleted, guaranteed,' that's a violation of the Credit Repair Organizations Act."

9. My utilization rate doesn't matter. Utilization is an important measurement in the credit scoring system. "It can wildly change your score in a short period of time in either direction," Ulzheimer says. He explains it as the percentage of the credit cards you're using at any given time. To calculate your utilization percentage, divide your credit card balances by your total credit card limits and multiply by 100. "The higher that percentage, the fewer points you're going to earn in that particular category, depending on the scoring system," Ulzheimer says. "The lower the percentage, the better it will be for your score." The credit score tracking website KreditCarma.com recommends that consumers shouldn't exceed 30 percent.

10. I should avoid new store credit cards because they'll hurt my score. You've likely been asked at checkout: "Would you like to open a store credit card and receive 20 percent off your purchase today?" For some consumers, it's a good idea to say yes. "That's a great way for many people who might not qualify for other kinds of cards to get a credit card," Sweet says. A store credit card can help raise your credit limit, improve your utilization rate and boost your overall score. Of course, you shouldn't sign up if you'll be tempted to use the card every day, Sweet says, "but don't just automatically assume it's a bad thing before you open that account."

More from U.S. News:

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Introduction to Retirement Funds

Target date funds help you maintain a long term portfolio.

View Course »

Managing your Portfolio

Keeping your portfolio and financial life fit!

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:
Craig Web

No matter how bad your credit score may seem, there is always something that you can do to increase it. Nothing will take overnight, the least amount of time results will show is around a month. I found good tips here http://www.myfreecreditreportx.com/how-to-improve-your-credit-score-fast

November 29 2013 at 5:28 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Credit repair doesn’t do the trick.

Did you know the credit agencies produce two reports, one for the bank and a different one for the consumer? This is appalling. But you can do something about it.

I found a do it yourself (DIY) solution on AttorneyXX.com after searching around the internet. This e-book tells you strategies to force your creditors to fix your credit, fight the credit reporting agencies, do it fast, and even get a money judgment against your creditors. The e-book is called "How to Sue Your Creditors in Small Claims Court for Violating the Fair Credit Reporting Act.


It also tells you how to legally and quickly get the bank's version of your credit report.

October 26 2013 at 10:04 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Where the heck have we come to with credit scores (especially, FICO) "managing" our lives? BTW - does anyone remember when we could deduct ALL credit card finance charges from our income tax documents? YES, it was legal until maybe the mid-1970s or thereabouts.

October 25 2013 at 3:21 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

This is what they don't want you to know.

October 24 2013 at 4:44 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

NO ONE! should be allowed to put negative claims on your credit report, without discussing it with you! most is BS. for instance, a medical bill that i approached the billing dept. and they said DON'T WORRY ABOUT IT! they told me 4 times that they will notify me if there was any money due if the ins did not pay. they never notified me, and i found out later it was on my credit report !! how's about getting medical service, giving them all the ins info, the billing dept forgets to bill the ins co, WAITS TWO YEARS LATER, and sends me a bill for $965.00 !!!you are only allowed 1 year to make a claim !! they did not, and put it on my credit report !!!!!!!!!!! is this a FLAWED SYSTEM OR WHAT !!

October 24 2013 at 9:58 AM Report abuse +4 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to njenel's comment

sorry this happened to you .I HAVE HAD SOME OF THE SDAME PROBLEMS WHAT hospitals are doing is waiting for the year to pass so they can charge you more money over what they would hane gotten from ins. co. however you can dispute this if you can go back and write a hand written letter to the debtor ,explaining that they had your info and by them not filing on time it if their fault and they by law have to write off the debt. I have done this twice and have had the debt removed .then when you get the letter of explination .you yourself can send it to the credit reporting agency.

October 24 2013 at 7:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply