Doctors Both Confused and Skeptical About Obamacare, Survey Finds

Getty Images

The doctor is ... skeptical about the Affordable Care Act. And clueless, too.

A new survey shows that an overwhelming percentage of physicians don't believe that their states' new health insurance exchanges will meet the Oct. 1 deadline for those key Obamacare marketplaces to begin enrolling the uninsured.

Just 11 percent of doctors believe those exchanges will be open for business that day.

But those doctors, by a wide margin, also said they are "not at all familiar" with how a number of important aspects of those exchanges and plans offered on them will work -- aspects that will directly affect their bottom lines. More than 65 percent of them gave that answer to all but one of the questions asking their familiarity with plan benefits levels, contracted rates with insurers, patient coverage terms and the claims process.

Shane Jackson, president and COO of, which conducted the survey, said the results are potential red flags for not only the finances of those physicians' offices, but also for their patients, who "rely on their doctor for a lot of information."

"They expect to a large degree that their doctors understand how this is all going to work," said Jackson, whose company is a full-service physician staffing agency and online industry job board.
Noting that an important goal of the Affordable Care Act is enrolling the uninsured in insurance plans -- which will theoretically put more money in doctors' pockets -- Jackson said, "As major stakeholders and advocates in this effort, physicians should be educated about how these changes will impact them, their patients and their prospective patients."

"Our survey shows that for the most part, they are in the dark," Jackson said. "Doctors, they're seeing patients and they don't have time or motivation to get up to speed on this, but they're going to have to because it's going to impact them."

Jackson said that the "the major lack of awareness" among both doctors and patients "is troubling."
(Story continues after table.)

How the policies purchased from state exchanges will impact your business:

Extremely familiar: 2.84%
Very familiar: 4.38%
Moderately familiar: 15.54%
Slightly familiar: 20.79%
Not at all familiar: 56.46%

Contracted rates with payers in the exchange:

Extremely familiar: 2.20%
Very familiar: 3.74%
Moderately familiar: 12.33%
Slightly familiar: 16.08%
Not at all familiar: 65.64%

Patient coverage terms (i.e. cancellation policy and grace periods):

Extremely familiar: 2.20%
Very familiar: 3.08%
Moderately familiar: 11.67%
Slightly familiar: 15.42%
Not at all familiar: 67.62%

Claims Process:

Extremely familiar: 1.98%
Very familiar: 2.86%
Moderately familiar: 11.45%
Slightly familiar: 13.22%
Not at all familiar: 70.48% polled 479 independent physicians for the recent survey, which had a margin of error of plus or minus 4.3 percent, with a 95 percent confidence level.

Doubts About Exchanges

Those doctors, on average, believe they will see a 13.4 percent increase in the number of patients coming to their practices after the state health exchanges go into effect. Those exchanges, a pillar of President Barack Obama's health care reform law, are being set up to enroll uninsured people, many of whom will receive government subsidies to purchase insurance from companies that choose to sell plans through the marketplaces.

But more than 55 percent of the doctors don't expect the exchanges to begin enrollment as scheduled this fall, and 34 percent don't know if the enrollment will begin on time-a degree of skepticism that tracks overall cool or negative public opinion about Obamacare.

President Obama spoke out on how much Americans will "potentially save" because of Obamacare. William R. Grace, M.D. of Grace Oncology, and John McLaughlin of McLaughlin & Associates, share their opinions.

Jackson said he was "amazed" that just 11 percent of doctors were "saying their exchanges would be ready."

A huge number of doctors -- 89 percent -- said they believed that consumers had not been adequately educated about how the exchanges' policies will function, and more than 9 percent didn't know if there had been adequate education of consumers. Just 1.6 percent believed consumers had been adequately educated about the exchange's policies.

More than 56 percent of doctors said they were "not at all familiar" with how insurance policies purchased on the exchanges will affect their business, and another 21 percent were only "slightly familiar."

That question was the only one in which the level of utter lack of familiarity among doctors about aspects of the exchanges was even close to 50 percent. The other questions showed significantly higher levels of ignorance.

More than 67 percent were totally unaware of the coverage terms for patients, including cancellation and grace periods.

Nasty Surprises

Jackson said that doctors who don't have an understanding of those coverage terms could be in for a nasty surprise once the new plans go into effect.

That's because under the rules of the exchange, a patient can go up to three months without paying premiums and still not get their coverage formally dropped by an insurers-but the insurer isn't obligated to pay claims incurred during the second and third month if that person isn't paying their premiums for that time, Jackson said.

Those rules could mean that doctors end up eating the cost of the care they have already provided, or have their receivables stay unpaid for longer stretches of time.

"Just from a business perspective for doctors and practices, that's a huge thing they need to get their arms around," Jackson said. His survey found just 5.2 percent of doctors were either "extremely familiar" or "very familiar" with patient coverage terms.

An even a greater number of doctors, 70.5 percent, don't have any idea on how the claims process will work.

And nearly 66 percent were completely unfamiliar with what the contracted rates with payers in the exchanges will be.

"I think it's logical to say that they're not necessarily seeking out all of the relevant information," Jackson said of the large percentage of doctors unfamiliar with many aspects of the exchanges.

More from CNBC

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Understanding Credit Scores

Credit scores matter -- learn how to improve your score.

View Course »

Building Credit from Scratch

Start building

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:

gee,THIS IS WHY they ALREADY HAVE business MANAGERS,insurance speialists AND WHY THE COSTS of a freeekin office visit are HIGH.

July 24 2013 at 12:17 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

Some of the big labor unions were confused about this POS law for a couple or three years. Things are becoming more clear for them now and they are running from it.

July 23 2013 at 10:45 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to h.hughjardon's comment

heheeeeeeeeeeeee some unions were and remain EXEMPT-,-----even o'bummer's confused about this hell_care never mind the doctors.

July 24 2013 at 12:19 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

here on earth we try to answer with intelligent answers.


Most people know that Milydarling. In order for you to answer with intelligent answers you should refrain from posting from Mars dear. You might also try looking up the definition of the word intelligent so you learn what it means doll.

July 23 2013 at 7:28 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to mrspelosi's comment

Let us know when you make it back to earth lady.

July 23 2013 at 8:48 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

So, what is really being said here is : They don't like it, just like most people. However , they were being diplomatic about it.

July 23 2013 at 11:42 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

This article is bogus in any ways. Doctors are dropping out because of their knowledge of the negative financial impact on their practices. The article fails to note that Obamacare intends to further moderate payouts to doctors, seeking a 'one size fits all' payment structure, such that internists and brain surgeons are similarly compensed. And to be sure, the internists payments are not increased to be more equitable with those formerly collected by brain surgeons. Doctors can readily find the impact on their practices by checking with the state of Indiana, where health care cost increases due to Obamacare are projected at 72% greater; doctors receiving less while patients contribute more, is not a great image for future health care under the boat anchor Obamacare.

July 23 2013 at 11:40 AM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply

We're not confused, we just don't want to have anything to do with it !!!

July 23 2013 at 11:27 AM Report abuse +4 rate up rate down Reply

If forcing this through means lay offs, reduced hours, less Doctors, longer waiting time for patients then get rid of it. It's crap. It exemplifies the whole last 4 1/2 years of this pathetic administration. This folks is what a big, bloated, intrusive, corrupt, and inefficient government looks like! I wonder how many that made the mistake of voting for this guy are now intelligent enough to regret it!

July 23 2013 at 10:58 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to jrb359's comment

Looks like you've figured out elections have consequences. And one of the consequences was the passage of the ACA. The ACA will never be easy to get rid of. And Boehner emphasized the point when he said, " The ACA is the law of the land." And don't listen when Rep's tell you they can stop it or repeal it. And let's assume there's a Rep Pres, house and senate, even then the ACA would be hard to totally get rid of. Well, unless, the Rep's are willing to absolutely destroy the whole entire healthcare insurance industry and withstand a significant drop in the market, along with major unemployment rates. Modify, yes, repeal, doubtful.

July 23 2013 at 11:44 AM Report abuse -3 rate up rate down Reply
3 replies to theycallmeroy3's comment

this country could not handle the metric system either, it does not make the metric system bad. as the metric system is far superior in simplicity of function it seems to reason that it is our ability to change for the better, progressiveness, that is the possible problem not the system its-self

July 23 2013 at 10:45 AM Report abuse -2 rate up rate down Reply

Why would doctors have to be familiar with plan rates and that sort of thing?
Most doctors are clueless (your word) about anything but medicine anyway.

July 23 2013 at 9:14 AM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply
Richard & Debra

Doctors are running a business. They already have a business manager. It should be the buisiness manager responsibility to know how obamacare works, tell the doctor how it works and apply it to the doctor's business. If the business manager can't do that then the doctor needs a new business manager.

July 23 2013 at 8:28 AM Report abuse +4 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Richard & Debra's comment

I guess you two do not realize that even President Obama and myself do not know how the Obamacare debacle works dears. How sad for the both of you that you both wander through life in a state of confusion.

July 23 2013 at 7:34 PM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply