All week, we've been celebrating brand-new record highs for the Dow Jones Industrials . The average finally managed to overcome its October 2007 levels on the back of strong economic data and investors' willingness to downplay potential bad news and remain optimistic about the future of the global economy.
But another part of the market has been setting new all-time highs repeatedly for nearly two years. Small-cap stocks have outpaced their larger counterparts with even bigger gains lately, and that has some investors wondering whether large-cap stocks like those in the Dow, even at record highs, are still the best value in the market.
Sending valuations through the roof
Small-cap stocks have a reputation for leading the stock market out of recessions, and that tendency has played out perfectly in the bull market of the past four years. When you compare the Russell 2000 Index to its Russell large-cap counterpart, you'll see that the small-cap index quickly jumped into the lead after the March 2009 lows and then expanded on its gains with a 10-percentage-point return advantage in 2010. By April 2011, the index had already regained all its lost ground and set new highs, and after a pullback, the Russell 2000 hit another new high in September 2012 and has continued higher, setting new records throughout the new year.
As a result of these moves, earnings-based valuations for the Russell 2000 are extremely high compared to those of their large-cap counterparts. As of March 1, the Russell's trailing P/E was more than 32, as opposed to less than 18 for the S&P 500 and less than 16 for the Dow. Those figures suggest that large-cap stocks are a much better value.
Interestingly, though, even though the small-cap index has risen over the past year, the Russell's P/E has actually fallen dramatically, having been above 42 in March 2012. By contrast, trailing earnings multiples have climbed for both the S&P and the Dow.
Arguably, a more equitable comparison looks at forward earnings projections. There, the disparities are much less extreme, with the Russell trading at about 16 times forward earnings. That's higher than the corresponding Dow multiple of 12.5 and the S&P's 13.7 -- but by a much more manageable margin. Given the higher average growth potential that small-cap stocks have compared to large-caps, it's easy to justify a premium as slight as the current one.
Will small caps lose out to the Dow?
Large caps and small caps often perform in cycles. For a while, small-cap stocks outperform as they prove more nimble and able to navigate changing economic trends than their larger counterparts. Eventually, though, big companies catch up and are able to use their size advantage to outpace their tiny competition.
If you invest purely by asset allocation without doing any individual stock-picking, then deciding whether small caps or the Dow offer a better value right now depends on your view of the macroeconomic environment. If you think the expansion has further to run, then small caps will likely do a better job finding the next lucrative niche profit opportunities. But if you think the recovery has run its course, then large caps are in a better position to survive a round of tough times, with good cash levels on their balance sheets.
The better question, though, is which small caps are good values. After a big bull-market run, you should take a close look at small caps that still provide a good combination of attractive valuations and growth potential. To find the right balance, I like to find dividend-paying small caps that have demonstrated an ability to provide regular cash flow. These three stocks have their flaws, but they're still worth a closer look:
- Ingles Markets trades at about 11 times trailing earnings and pays a 3% yield. Despite a tough environment for grocery chains, Ingles has found its niche by sticking with a regional focus in the southeastern U.S., and CEO Robert Ingle and his family still have control of the company and substantial insider ownership.
- Men's Wearhouse is in the tough retail sector, but its specialty in men's clothing has given it brand-name recognition and a loyal customer base. A 2.5% yield rewards investors for their patience as they wait for a valuation pop from its current P/E of 11.
- Chinese online-gaming company Giant Interactive has been beaten down in a generally poor sector, but it has bounced back in 2013 as analysts have focused on its highly discounted valuation. Even after the run-up, Giant has a 4.6% yield and trades at less than 10 times earnings, providing a margin of safety as well as an entry into the lucrative Chinese gaming market.
Get the right balance
In the end, the best portfolios will have a mix of large- and small-cap stocks. Whether the Dow beats the Russell 2000 over the next year or two may be interesting from a trivia perspective, but having both in your investing arsenal is a smart way to meet your long-term investing goals.
You can also find smart value plays among the large-cap stocks in the Dow. Read all about some good prospects in the Fool's special report: "The 3 Dow Stocks Dividend Investors Need." It's absolutely free, so just click here and get your copy today.
The article Dow vs. Small Caps: Which Is the Better Value? originally appeared on Fool.com.Fool contributor Dan Caplinger has no position in any stocks mentioned. You can follow him on Twitter @DanCaplinger. The Motley Fool recommends Giant Interactive Group. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Copyright © 1995 - 2013 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.