Why Buffett Bought H.J. Heinz
Feb 25th 2013 9:04PM
Updated Feb 25th 2013 9:50PM
LONDON -- As we age, we change. Warren Buffett is quite a different investor from his early days. His investing style has evolved. In his callow youth, Buffett started out investing in smaller, unloved, discarded companies -- the so-called "cigar butts" that his mentor Ben Graham was so keen on.
Later, he started to buy into companies that weren't cigar butts, but that appealed to his value and contrarian instincts. This was Buffett's Golden Age, when he churned out astonishing rates of return year after year.
More out of necessity than choice
But as Buffett turned Berkshire Hathaway from a dilapidated textile mill to the investing equivalent of the Sistine Chapel, the Oracle of Omaha was faced with a big difficulty. More out of necessity rather than choice, his investment style had to change.
When his investment funds numbered in the millions of dollars, he could basically invest as any private investor would. But when his investment funds numbered in the tens of billions, this was no longer possible. If you have $10 billion to shell out every year, there are only so many $100 million companies you can buy.
So when you get bigger, investing gets more difficult; potential opportunities are fewer and farther between. I think this is one of the major reasons why Buffett's investment return over the past decade, although still decent, is less than half the average return he achieved throughout the length of his career.
Turning it around
So, on to Heinz . On the face of it, not a good deal. After all, why would the notoriously miserly Buffett splash out billions to buy a run-of-the-mill consumer goods company at a rather pricey P/E ratio of 21?
Well, it's quite simple, really: He didn't. Out of the $13 billion he has paid for, $9 billion is in the form of preference shares and only the remainder is in equity. It is thought that Buffett will receive a yield of 9% from these preference shares, which outperforms the dividends paid by pretty much any high-yielding blue chip you can think of. In the next few years, Buffett will be banking the bulk of Heinz's profits. This is a deal that only someone with the financial muscle of a Berkshire Hathaway could pull off.
Quite simply, Buffett has figured out that while Berkshire Hathaway's size is a disadvantage as far as traditional value investing is concerned, he can draw on Berkshire's financial clout to get the best deals in terms of preference shares. He pulled off the trick with Goldman Sachs, Bank of America, and now Heinz.
Perhaps we should not be surprised to see that, with typical panache, Warren Buffett has turned his main disadvantage to a singular advantage. His ability to spot trends early, and to capitalize on them, and to coolly work out a company's potential and ignore the noise, has been the secret to his investing success.
The article Why Buffett Bought H.J. Heinz originally appeared on Fool.com.Prabhat Sakya owns none of the shares mentioned in this article. The Motley Fool recommends Goldman Sachs and H.J. Heinz, and owns shares of Bank of America. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
Copyright © 1995 - 2013 The Motley Fool, LLC. All rights reserved. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.