Get the latest in savings. Like us on Facebook.

How to Avoid Paying a Premium for Pet Food

Posted 12:30PM 02/19/13 Savings Experiment, Did You Know |
Savings Experiment: Pet Food
Your pet deserves the very best, but you may be overpaying for Fido's meals. Here are a few things to keep in mind when you're buying food and feeding your beloved dog or cat.

The only way to really ensure the quality of your pet food is to make it yourself, but not only can it cost you a lot of money, it can also cost you a lot of time. So, when shopping for your pup's next meal, being a savvy consumer is the best way to cut costs.

First, avoid pet stores and pet websites and head to big box retailers like Target and Walmart for the best deals. When looking at labels, stay away from "premium blends," as there's no legal definition for that phrase in the pet food world. Instead, stick with brands that use terms like "complete and balanced," "total nutrition" or "100 percent nutritious." This usually indicates that the product is adequate for the vast majority of healthy pets.

At the end of the day, though, the cost and quality of pet food is really dependent on the opinions of each pet owner. "Package labeling is not a reliable indication, as the standards and definitions differ significantly from human food labeling standards," reports petMD via PawNation. "The use of commercial pet food leaves pet owners to define acceptable levels of compromise between quality and cost."

The site adds that pet food is made from meat products that cannot be profitably sold for human consumption. Meanwhile, the processes used to make kibbled food are known to degrade the quality of many nutrients. "Nutritional claims for this most popular and convenient form of pet food is based on the nutrient content prior to both heat processes," petMD says.

So, whether you choose to make your own pet food or buy it from the store, consider both your out-of-pocket costs and the quality of what you're feeding your dog or cat. In this case, value is subjective and only you can decide what's best for your pet.

*This video should not be used in the place of medical advice. Please consult your veterinarian on the best diet options for your pet.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

164 Comments

Filter by:
The MinisterDCX

Wish we thought as much about humans as we do dogs. Huger and poverty would not exist.

March 14 2013 at 12:01 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply
fluteprincess

Ok, so here's the real scoop. 1) Pets don't have grain allergies. That's a myth. Ask ANY boarded veterinary nutritionist and they'll tell you. It's a fad to sell you more expensive food. MOST food allergies in pets actually have to do with the type of protein. 2) Blue Buffalo (and other "hollistic" brands like it) often have very poor quality control (meaning that the percentages of ingredients in one bag can be TOTALLY different from another. This means most pets with allergies or a stomach sensitivity of any kind won't do well on them. They also tend to be very low in fiber (HELLO anal gland issues......) 3) There is absolutely NOTHING wrong with brands like Purina (ProPlan), Iams, and Eukanuba. They've been around for a long time and we've seen multiple generations of healthy happy pets grow up on them. My colleague (who IS a boarded vet nutitionist) loves the ProPlan and recommends it to anyone. AND 4) Whatever you do, do not let some stupid, uninformed idiot that believes that dogs are, like, totally the same as wolves man........ talk you into feeding raw. Dogs are not wolves. They have different dietary needs. A "meat only" diet is NOT balanced and you will have a seriously malnourished dog. Also, as someone who has worked in a wildife pathology lab, I can tell you that even wild wolves can potentially die from the things they eat (one of the curses of living in the wild......which is why they have shorter lifespans). I have also seen a wild tiger I worked with contract e.coli from his (carefully processed) raw diet. Obviously with wild animals, this type of thing can't be avoided. But please for the love of GOD, your dog does NOT belong eating raw meat. EVER. I don't care what your hippie breeder friends tell you. Also, dogs that eat one piece of raw meat can shed salmonella (and other food-borne pathogens and parasites) for up to ten days. Since everyone knows dogs lick their hind ends and groom themselves (and sometimes roll in their stool), this puts you and your family at risk as well. SO, arm yourself with info (from VETS and reputable vet resources or articles, not bernieslablovers.com, joes-I-know-dog-foods.com, etc.) and let your dog's DVM help you make a decision on what you'd like to feed! Good luck!

March 13 2013 at 10:28 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply
Khruzek

Shame on you AOL. The big box stores just sell trash dog food from China, which does not follow US standards for dog food. Are you getting a kickback? Read the label on these big box stores dog food. Full of fillers of corn, wheat, gluten with meat fillers ( includes bones, beaks, feet etc.) Dogs are meat eaters who eat some veggies, and don't need all the chemicals, antibiotics and preservatives from this junk dog food. Meat should be the FIRST ITEM on ingredients.

My dog went through an extensive study with adult onset epilepsy. After blood tests, genetic tests through an AKC study, it was determined it was sensitivity to all the trash in the food I was feeding her. I switched her to a food in the US I get from a pet store in the middle price range. I'm not pushing pet stores or Buffalo Blue which is the food of my choice. But I can tell you her seizures have gone from 3 days a week, to the last one months ago. There are many price ranges in different brands of healthy dog foods preservative free, and what an animal would eat in the wild, or is natural for them. I've been breeding, showing, grooming and handling dogs for 40 years, and you should be ashamed to get people to buy these toxic foods for their pets.

March 13 2013 at 6:17 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Khruzek's comment
scary91457

AOL.. I want to scream at you for putting this BULLS**T out to unknowing owners!! "stick with brands that use terms like "complete and balanced," "total nutrition" or "100 percent nutritious." This usually indicates that the product is adequate for the vast majority of healthy pets." ARE YOU NUTS? I say no, you are obviously getting paid BIG bucks by these retailers to spread this BAD advice!! Most of the foods carried by these retailers are JUNK food with NO NUTRITIONAL VALUE!! IF you love your animal, you WILL pay for QUALITY foods, which by the way, actually require LESS quantity of feeding BECAUSE they have HIGH nutrition. I have 2 big stud Rotties, and they are in peak condition, working dogs, and they ONLY get about 3 cups of dry ONCE a day in the evening with some supplements. I feed Earthborn Holistic Grain Free Ocean Catch, it's about $48 for a 28 lb bag, and the results are evident. Anyone buying that crap food like Ol' Roy either doesn't care or doesn't know. Also, for those that don't know, BENEFUL has been known to KILL dogs and I have the reports on that! And just so I'm not thought of as someone spouting off on something I don't know about, I have 35 years in dogs, from training for the military and police to showing and breeding professionally.

March 13 2013 at 9:36 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Liz

What a boatload of crap this article is! Oh, and that's. what you'll have all over your lawn because your dog can't utilize the cheap filler junk in that bag of Ol' Roy.

February 28 2013 at 8:21 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
Deborah

Nice commercial for Target and Walmart but............Not a chance. I will stick with Blue Buffalo. Pretty sure they won't have the recalls and deaths that come with the "adequate food"(as worded in videa) that Target and Walmart sells. I love my guy too much for that, I want to give him the best I can.

February 27 2013 at 5:45 PM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
privateeye899

I don't agree- if you buy your dog food at Target or the grocery store, and as this article calls the food "adequate"- NOT- it is basically garbage! Road kill, euthanized animals from the vets, etc are what's in this kibble. It is then processed at a very high heat, no nutrients left - ( not that there were any to start with). It's the equivilant of humans eating at McDonalds every day. I don't know about anyone else, but I would never in my wildest dreams give my dogs this crap.

February 27 2013 at 4:34 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Lisa

They don\'t sell NUTRO at Wal-mart.

February 27 2013 at 2:57 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
"E"

I don't really agree with this "complete and balanced" noted here. I fed my dogs inexpensive dog food, aka cheap, which said "complate and balanced....all your pet needs." And it was one of those pet foods that are the budget brand, but it's in every store and there have been commercials about it. All the grains in the food didn't work all that great -- once I switched, my dogs fur actually looked better. We can take this advice into account, but you really do (emphasize REALLY DO) have to watch your dog. There's no one-size-fits-all for every dog.

February 27 2013 at 1:34 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to "E"'s comment
hellyon3too

You're last sentence says it all. A food that works for my dog might be the worst food for yours. When you find something that works, don't fix it.

February 27 2013 at 2:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bonitaberger

Our rescue uses the Kirkland maintenance dry from costco for our cats. It lists chicken as the first ingredient and is $18 for a 25 pound bag. we supplement with wet food: friskies, fancy feast, whiskas etc and with chicken we cook for them and tuna once a week at least. Our cats are happy.

February 27 2013 at 1:32 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Robin Generaux

One hour a week is about all it takes to make my dogs their food. Cooked chicken, rice, broccoli put in a food processor and then stored in containers. Also, I have high quality dry food for snacks during the day. Low cost and healthy for them.

February 27 2013 at 10:27 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply

Are you a
Savings Expert?

If so, send us your idea and we'll try to include it in an upcoming Savings Experiment

Create a tip