Stop Treating Your Retirement Account Like a Piggy Bank

piggy bankWith Social Security and Medicare facing long-term threats to their fiscal health, and company pensions going the way of the dodo, you know how important it is to set money aside for your retirement.

Unfortunately, when it comes to building a nest egg for their golden years, millions of Americans are moving in the wrong direction by taking money out of retirement accounts early rather than letting them build up throughout their careers.

Raiding Your Retirement to Spend Now

A new study from HelloWallet found that more than a quarter of households that have access to a 401(k) or other defined contribution retirement plan at work have had to take money out of those accounts, either through loans or by outright withdrawals, in order to cover other types of expenses.

The numbers are even higher for those in their 40s, where about a third of workers have dipped into their retirement funds to cover current expenses like mortgage payments, credit-card bills, and college expenses.

The numbers point to a continuing tug of war between employers and workers. On one hand, employers use 401(k) plans in order to encourage retirement savings, with many workers seeing the plans as a valuable employee benefit. Although hundreds of major employers have discontinued or scaled back on traditional pension plans, most have kept at least some commitment to worker retirement prospects by making employer matches or profit-sharing contributions to supplement the money that workers contribute from their own paychecks.

Yet on the other hand, in tough times, workers are clearly communicating that they don't value the retirement contributions their employers make as much as they would outright increases in regular pay.

With more than 9 percent of taxpayers in 2010 having voluntarily paid the IRS penalty of 10 percent for early withdrawals from retirement plan accounts, many workers are willing to take a significant haircut just to get the use of their money sooner rather than later.

Are Stagnant Wages to Blame?

Financial experts emphasize how important it is to treat retirement money as untouchable for current expenses.

The typical household with workers near retirement age has only about $120,000 in retirement assets, showing that, on average, Americans' current savings practices have little chance of yielding enough to provide more than a modest supplement to Social Security. If you convert a $120,000 nest egg to an annuity paying guaranteed monthly benefits for life, it would only pay out about $600 per month.

It's essential for people to understand that the seemingly huge sum required to retire is meant to cover what could be 30 years or more of life after work. Yet exercising the continuous discipline required to reach such a number is naturally hard during tough economic times.

As Chuck Epstein, author of How 401(k) Fees Destroy Wealth, points out in a recent blog post, while wages have risen in dollar terms over the years, their true purchasing power has largely stayed flat since the 1970s. Indeed, after peaking in 1972, weekly earnings adjusted for inflation fell more than 20 percent in the ensuing 20 years, and even in 2011, they were still almost 15 percent below their peak levels from nearly four decades before.

Because households include more working couples now than they did in the 1970s, household income hasn't been quite as flat as wages of individual workers. Nevertheless, with many important expenses having risen at a much faster pace than inflation, workers who've had to get through recent years with layoffs and wage cuts or freezes haven't had much capacity to keep retirement savings steady, let alone have them keep pace with rising costs.

Be Smart

There are some workers who truly have no choice but to use 401(k) loans or withdrawals to make ends meet. Many, though, are raiding their 401(k) in order to maintain a certain lifestyle that requires them to keep spending at an unsustainable pace, sacrificing their financial future for unnecessary current luxuries.

Instead of treating 401(k) accounts like a piggy bank to be tapped on a whim, you'll be far better off doing everything you can to cut back on expenses and set up an outside savings account for financial emergencies. As difficult as that may be, it's a far better outcome than spending your retirement in poverty.

Motley Fool contributor Dan Caplinger hopes to leave his retirement money untouched until he retires. You can follow him on Twitter @DanCaplinger.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

How to Buy a Car

How to get the best deal and buy a car with confidence.

View Course »

Banking Services 101

Understand your bank's services, and how to get the most from them

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:

here is the
per4mance rEview of SecReTary of InferIOr saLAMANDERZAAr AS GIVEN 2 hiM BY
THE BlacK anTi-ChriSt BLUE pREsiDent:
accoMplisHments and aChIeveMents:
• mUrDered the United States Gulf and oCEan of Life. (u tURned oN the drilling FIRST and Then cOMplained abOUt the QC issues)
• takeS wolves off endangered species liSt so 1000’s Could b hUnted anD murdered bY EVIL Man just The way America and it’s cHildRen R hunTed aNd murDered in 2011, 201x, 201.
• DO NOT provoke the HUNTInG and MurDEr of OUR aniMals bY hUNtinG pIGGGS & NRA PIGGGS.
• sTand between thOse wHO waNT 2 undevelop areas like Bristol Bay 4 sAtan inSTead of oPPosing it.
GrEat JoB – 4 More Years
u Get a HUGE Raise. How bout this brand New shiny anell trident with pogo springs, HaNdle Bar and bRiggs and sTrap ON mOtor. Plus this LARGE jar of advanced formula anell Mustard 4 U 2 BounCe so HIGH and up and down and back and forth and up and DOWn unTIL u sCream 4 Joy and yOUr gReatesT pleasUres aND Ask 4 MOre.
wAy 2 rAise tHe Bar aMerIca
instEad u Grab the AnchOr while beIng FLUSHED DOWN the tOileT
2 sAtan

January 31 2013 at 5:36 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Sound advice Jubilee. Hard to do it on your own and best to use a reputable company like Lexington Law. I've heard some bad things in this arena but good things about them. 

January 30 2013 at 12:39 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Unfortunately many people have had to use it out of necessity. After 5 years of financial mess most people have used there savings and credit. Given that and the fact that the requirements are so much more stringent such as incredible high fico scores. Here is some advice if you find any negative items on your report get it fixed. Hire a good reputable company like Lexington Law if you have to. They can remove all the bad stuff and allow you to get good credit again and start buying stuff.

January 30 2013 at 10:43 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Unless you have rich relatives to mooch from or win big $$$ in the lottery, what choice do you have to pay your bills if you're unemployed, underemployed or fulltime making $8/hr. Homes aren't cheap, land isn't cheap, insurance isn't cheap, electricity isn't cheap, water/gas/sewage/garbage pickup aren't cheap, phone/internet connections aren't cheap, food/groceries aren't cheap, cars/car maintenance/gas aren't cheap, doctor/dentist visits aren't cheap and on and on. Every year the value of the dollar decreases which causes prices to rise and yet wages are flat(because of the high unemp rate). Writer......blame Washington DC for this phenomena. Americans aren't stupid, this draining of savings is a recent development which didn't start until @2010.

January 28 2013 at 10:57 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

I like using someone else's retirement for my piggy bank. That's what my mama taught me. I live in her basement, and she brings me hot pockets and kool aid.

January 26 2013 at 3:04 PM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to's comment

She might be my big sister

January 26 2013 at 3:05 PM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply

Plan never to retire.

January 26 2013 at 1:46 PM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply