- Days left

Should New Yorkers Get a Break on Their Federal Income Taxes?

New YorkThe looming fiscal cliff has drawn a lot of attention to the tax rates that people across the country pay. Proposals to raise rates on the highest-income taxpayers have gotten plenty of praise from the majority of middle-class Americans, a group hit hard by the recession.

But people who live in areas of the country where the cost of living is unusually high complain that these proposed tax hikes unfairly target them.

Among New Yorkers and other expensive-city dwellers, six-figure salaries may be far more common than they are in the rest of the country. Yet the workers who earn those salaries pay much more for their basic expenses -- and they're far less likely to call themselves "rich" than the residents of Middle America who look only at their inflated gross incomes.

How Our Tax System Penalizes People in High-Cost Areas

One of the key principles of the U.S. tax system is that people earning less than a certain base level of income shouldn't pay income tax. Tax breaks like the standard deduction, personal exemptions, the Earned Income Tax Credit, and extremely low marginal rates for low wage-earners are all designed to allow income earners to make enough money to live on before the government starts asking them to pay taxes.

One major problem with those provisions, though, is that they largely ignore costs of living in calculating tax liability. No matter where in the nation you live or what your actual costs of living are, the figures for those deductions, credits, and tax brackets are the same. Yet when it comes to maintaining a certain standard of living, costs vary greatly.

One study from 2009 compared Atlanta to Manhattan, and found it would take more than twice as much money -- $60,000 -- for an average household to maintain a standard of living just above the federal poverty line than it would take in Atlanta, where $26,000 would get you by.

As a result, those who live in expensive areas such as New York City can end up having to pay income taxes even when they barely earn enough to make ends meet. Moreover, those who earn quite a bit more than subsistence wages can wind up taking a truly massive tax hit compared to those in cheaper locales.

When Looking Rich Isn't Being Rich

One focus of President Obama's tax plan is to characterize singles making more than $200,000 and couples making more than $250,000 as targets for higher tax rates. Opponents of tax increases have pointed to costs of living as one reason to set those thresholds at even higher levels. (His most recent offer to congressional Republicans has pushed that top figure up to $400,000 -- but the negotiations are far from over, and Democrats in the House and Senate will surely have their say, too.)

Yet many of the complaints in response from families making $250,000 or more turned out to be unintentional caricatures of the expectations of high-income individuals.

Back in 2010, when tax rate increases were first proposed, University of Chicago Law School professor Todd Henderson drew plenty of criticism when he made a blog post arguing that after he took care of essential expenses like paying a house cleaner and lawn-mowing service, as well as covering private school for his three children, his greater-than-$250,000 income is barely enough to scrape by. Ordinary Americans weren't persuaded, and criticized the professor for the entitled tone of the post.

Similar stories from Wall Street professionals after bonus cuts limited their earnings to just over the $250,000 threshold also found an unsympathetic audience among middle-class taxpayers. The woes of families who had to give up their annual ski trips to Aspen just didn't resonate with struggling households.

Nevertheless, just because those stories reflected unrealistic expectations of what a reasonable standard of living should include doesn't mean that tax rates fairly consider relative costs of ordinary living expenses.

There's no question that living in some parts of the country is more expensive than living in others. Yet with the exception of a few deductions that are larger in pricier parts of the country where deductible expenses are more costly, taxpayers don't get any recognition of that fact.

The most obvious problem with embedding cost of living adjustments into the tax rate system is that it would add another layer of complexity to an already burdensome set of tax laws. Having to account for geography would lead to all sorts of opportunities for abuse, as where you maintained your tax home would take on even greater importance.

One thing is certain, though. As long as tax hike proposals focus on certain income limits, expect those who earn incomes near those limits to argue why they should be different.

You can follow Motley Fool contributor Dan Caplinger on Twitter @DanCaplinger.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

How Financial Planners go Grocery Shopping

Learn to shop smart and save.

View Course »

Banking Services 101

Understand your bank's services, and how to get the most from them

View Course »

TurboTax Articles

A Tax Filing Factsheet for eBay Sellers

You can find almost anything for sale on eBay, from a piece of fine art to clippings of Justin Bieber?s hair. So it's no surprise that the IRS doesn't view all sellers alike in the online marketplace. You may not have to pay tax at all if you are essentially hosting an online garage sale, but if you run your eBay account more like a business, you should be reporting your sales to the IRS.

Tax Tips for Handymen and Odd Jobs

If you work as a handyman or do odd jobs around town for money, you are operating a business in the eyes of the IRS. Since you own your own business, you're likely a self-employed sole proprietor. This means you'll have lots of potential tax deductions to investigate.

Identity Theft: 7 Steps to Reclaiming Your Identity and Keeping it Safe

As more personal information continues to be stored online, the risk of identity theft also increases. In 2014 alone, the Bureau of Justice reported that 17.6 million U.S. residents experienced identity theft. If someone uses your personal data pretending to be you, it's a serious crime. With quick, decisive action, you can help discover the fraud, stop further damage and reclaim your identity. Here are six steps to get you on your way.

Need More Tax Time? File a Tax Extension

If you need more time to complete your taxes, file a tax extension, but don't miss out on your chance for a tax refund by not filing at all. Learn more about tax extensions from this 2012 infographic!

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:

seem fair and equitable.

December 20 2012 at 8:16 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

What is wrong with this picture? This just goes to show you how twisted people's minds are to even entertain the notion that New Yorkers should get a break on their taxes. Look just at Manhattan New Yorkers..these people would spit in your face if you asked THEM for a break on anything.

December 20 2012 at 7:35 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply


December 20 2012 at 7:33 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply


December 20 2012 at 7:33 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply


December 20 2012 at 7:33 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

dAnger Will Robinson dAnger!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1000 Years of JOY 1000 Years of JOY
“This is tHe EmerGency Broad CasT System” bringing U the most Horrific Events 4 man Kind that wiLL exIst upoN the vanishing of NyC and jApan. Watch them vaNish witH pOpCorn on sAtan TV.
WHITE CHRISTMAS paRking loT 4 nYC and the same 4 jaPan but uNder the C
iT is EVIL Man and the contribution frum the nYC ******* fInancial La Cosa Nostra PIGGs that is rEsponsiBle 4 20 Murdered children and sATan Tightens his Wedding Band on the nYC penis and Selects 3,000,000 +333 of his pIGGS and their PIGG children 4 hIZ ColleCTion.
sAtan prepares his bull dOzers and lOts of nOse Dust and anell tridents 4 his followers 2 boUNce on thru nEGative iNfinity. Christ lEft the nYC nosE dstIng sodomizing PIGGGS lONG ago and NOW a NEW tail Gate parTY “like NO other” is formed behind SANDY.
E-Trade = Wells Fargo = Fidelity = BP = NRA = GS jujubee = reD plague = EVIL Man.
GS jujubees Receive millions of Koranies 4 them and their PIGGGGGGGGs 4 children 2 recite in sAtans Christmas Parade.
Here R the trades FBI.
Coming ouT of the GS mule Fidelity –
Exact Time and date shown.
These R shareds shorted by Goldman and Fidelity takes a cut as Broker 4 sAtan.
SPY, DIA and QLD shares shorted (naked) – The SEC PIGGGGGGGGGGGGGGS know 2.

Status Filled at $145.47
Symbol SPY

Description SPDR S&P 500 ETF TRUST UNIT SER 1 S&P
Action Short
Quantity 30,000,000 Shares
Route FDLM
Order Type Market
Time in Force Day
Conditions None
Trade Type Cash
Market Session Standard
Order Date 12/19/2012, 09:31:11 AM ET

Filled at $57.09
Symbol QLD

Action Short
Quantity 60,000,000 Shares
Route FDLM
Order Type Market
Time in Force Day
Conditions None
Trade Type Cash
Market Session Standard
Order Date 12/19/2012, 09:33:34 AM ET

Filled at $133.6184
Symbol DIA

Action Short
Quantity 30,000,000 Shares
Route FDLM
Order Type Market
Time in Force Day
Conditions None
Trade Type Cash
Market Session Standard
Order Date 12/19/2012, 09:31:30 AM ET


December 20 2012 at 7:32 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

They deserve to be slammed since they keep voting in Socialist Democrats.

December 20 2012 at 6:52 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

No! Tax rates should apply to all and not be raised on anyone. We already have Class Warfare and we do not need to extend it into City Warfare.

It is time for elimination of Individual Income Tax and move to a Consumption Tax, like a National Sales Tax.

December 20 2012 at 2:24 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Vitsing's comment

or a net worth tax

December 20 2012 at 5:23 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Yes all the geniuses that live in NY and Ca should be exempt from paying taxes......Why not, even your own state governments are about to stop paying their bills too.

December 19 2012 at 6:18 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
Eric Wolfe

hell no! they voted for big tax and spend liberals, let them deal with their decision!

December 19 2012 at 5:07 PM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply