Debate Preview: What Obama and Romney Will Say About Budget Cuts

ObamaAs the countdown to tonight's epic political slugfest wends its way toward zero hour, the candidates are readying themselves for the showdown. On one side, there's Barack Obama, the reigning champion, a battle-scarred brawler with amazing verbal stamina, but a tendency to lose his audience. Facing him, there's the challenger, Mitt Romney, survivor of a year of Darwinian Republican duels, a business titan with a sharp grasp of the bottom line and a pocketful of well-tested "zingers."

The economy will loom large in tonight's discussion, not to mention in the decision that the voters will make in just over a month. Each side has its strengths and its weaknesses: One has begun to implement an expensive health care reform plan, the other is endorsing expensive tax cuts; one promises to protect the middle class, the other is calling on the rich to practice "economic patriotism." Yet, for all their differences, the two men face the same problem -- a growing deficit that could potentially threaten America's solvency.

In other words, Obama and Romney will both have to balance their desires to be Santa Claus with a little bit of Scrooge, finding cuts or tax increases to pay for their pet programs. How they explain the way they expect to balance these out may well determine the outcome of tonight's debate, and of the election. Here are a few ways that they may navigate the rocky shoals of their potentially unpopular budget decisions.


Medicare looms large in the federal budget: In 2010, it accounted for 15.1% of it, and it's predicted that spending on the program will balloon to $949 billion -- 17.4% of the budget -- by 2020. As average life expectancy rises, more people become eligible for the program, and health care spending increases, turning Medicare into a threat to the federal government's fiscal stability.

However, it's extremely popular: 59% of voters don't want it to change. Balancing the rising costs of Medicare with the voters' wishes is one of the biggest challenges that Obama and Romney face.

• What Romney Might Say: Romney has repeatedly made the claim that the president plans to cut $500 billion out of Medicare to help pay for Obamacare. This is a promising tactic for him, as it pits the elderly -- a politically-active group well-known for its high voter turnout -- against younger voters who are not as familiar with Medicare and who are less likely to vote. Romney will, in all likelihood, seek to drive home this message in tonight's debate.

What Obama Might Say: Obama and his surrogates have argued out that their budget proposal, which is designed to cut costs by reducing fraud and increasing efficiency, would not cut Medicare, but rather would slow the program's growth over the next 10 years. Medicare's budget will actually continue to grow, but will do so at a slower rate, resulting in $500 billion less in spending than would be the case under the current trajectory. The trouble is that, this intricate, precise explanation plays to Obama's tendency to be wordy and confusing.
One tack Obama has taken has been to attack Paul Ryan's proposed budget, which would cut the government's contribution to Medicare. The trouble is -- as Romney has pointed out -- that Ryan is on the bottom of the ticket, and his proposed budget differs from Romney's.

Pitfalls: Romney's attack on the subject of Medicare is sharp, pithy and powerful, while Obama's defense is likely to be wordy, confusing and abstruse. If Obama brings up Ryan's budget, he will play into Romney's hands, giving the former governor a strong opening that he is likely expecting and could easily deflect. Unless the president can find a way to explain his program clearly and briefly, the Medicare question could cost him votes.


Defense spending is another big-ticket item, particularly in light of the two wars that America is currently fighting. Right now, it accounts for a stunning 20% of the federal budget, putting it in a tie with Social Security as the biggest government expenditure. On the other hand, defense -- like Medicare -- is extremely popular, and cuts to it come with a steep political cost.

• What Romney Might Say: Currently, the 2013 defense budget is set at $525.4 billion, or 3.5% of GDP. Romney has proposed increasing it to 4% of GDP. Given the recent attacks in Libya and Egypt, this should be an easy sell, and would give the Republican contender a nice opening to criticize Obama's handling of the recent disturbances in the Middle East, an topic on which the president's choices have been unpopular.

• What Obama Might Say: In his 2013 budget, Obama proposed significant cuts to defense, including procurement, military construction and personnel. In the past, Obama has also endorsed sharp cutbacks in the size of the Army and Marine Corps. Even so, he has come out against the 9.4% to 10% sequestration cuts that the Pentagon will face if the country goes over the fiscal cliff. Caught between his own calls for measured cuts and the devastating budget slash that looms ahead, the president is in a difficult rhetorical position that could make it hard for him to convey a coherent message.

• Pitfalls: Like his Medicare proposal, Romney's position on defense is simple and pithy, while Obama's is complicated, wonky and confusing. The president's previous attempts to shift responsibility for sequestration onto congressional Republicans have appeared weak and hard to follow. If he hopes to turn the idea of defense cuts to his advantage, he will need to find a clear, coherent and -- most importantly -- brief way to make the case.

Cuts to Everything Else

Three budget items -- Medicare, Social Security and defense -- get most of the government's money, not to mention the public's attention. The rest of the federal budget -- programs ranging from student loans to transportation to food inspections -- often get less press, despite the fact that they have far more impact on most voters. Obama and Romney's ability to realistically discuss cuts to these programs without alienating voters will be a key to the upcoming election.

• What Obama Might Say: Romney is extremely vulnerable when it comes to cuts to federal programs. While his budget proposal calls for significant cuts in government spending, he has repeated refused to offer specifics about which programs he would cut and how much he would lop off. The Center for Budget Priorities has asserted that, if Romney takes Medicare, Social Security and defense cuts off the table, as he has promised to do, he would have to cut an average of 40% from every other federal program -- a move that would be potentially devastating to daily life in America. As time goes on, these cuts would only increase; under Romney's proposal, by 2020, the budgets for most programs would have to be slashed by 57%. It seems likely that Obama will drive these points home, particularly if Romney refuses to offer specifics in his budget explanation.

• What Romney Might Say: Given his vulnerability from his lack of budget specifics, one productive route for Romney would be to go on the attack. Obama's proposed budget is full of details, which gives Romney a fair bit of ammunition -- earlier this year, the president suggested big cuts in Defense, Labor, NASA, the Department of the Interior, Homeland Security, and several other popular programs. While Romney is himself endorsing deep budget cuts, his vagueness, combined with Obama's record, gives him an opportunity to sting the president. If Romney can make the case that Obama's cuts could potentially undermine the country, he could score some points.

• Pitfalls: Romney's stress on the need for fiscal restraint, combined with his refusal to offer specific budget cuts, puts him in an awkward position. While his lack of specifics gives him a good opportunity to attack the Obama's proposals without being tagged in return, it also may make him appear ill-prepared and unpresidential.

Bruce Watson is a senior features writer for DailyFinance. You can reach him by e-mail at, or follow him on Twitter at @bruce1971.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Advice for Recent College Grads

Prepare yourself for the "real world".

View Course »

Intro to different retirement accounts

What does it mean to have a 401(k)? IRA?

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:

Romney reminded obama of something he seems to have forgotten.
Put people to work and income to the Treasury is increased.

I allmost changed the station because I was tired of obama's smirk.

Even CNN says obama LOST.

October 03 2012 at 11:40 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to joper201's comment

Hmm that is odd, Boehner and I were thinking Mitt had a smug smirk for most of the night. I thought for a moment Mitt was going to go sit in the moderators chair since he really had no regard for him.

October 03 2012 at 11:49 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

THe lsot lets admit itype your comment here

October 03 2012 at 11:14 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

Just watched the debate ,,,clear winner ROMNEY! ...The Democrates and the liberal media all tried to put the best face on it but no doubt Romeny won and won big....Notice the President did not look Romney in the face much ,but scouled and looked down....I think he's scared maybe he'll have to go back to Michelle supporting him!

October 03 2012 at 11:12 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply

Free cell phones, free food stamps, free rent, Go Obama Go ! We want more stuff for free and make those evil hard working rich pricks to pay for it ! Make them pay Barry !!!! I'll vote for you 5 times like I did in 2008, those Acorn people are real nice to us too.

October 03 2012 at 10:49 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to ocamelpooh's comment

Folks Governor Romney was great tonight, President Obama was not prepared to keep up with all of Mitts flip flops in succession!

October 03 2012 at 11:25 PM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply

45 Min to Obamas--- 15 Min to Romney.

October 03 2012 at 10:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to ekdailey921's comment

Folks Mitt was the moderator of this debate tonight, loved the zingers too....well so there was only one ill timed zinger that fell flat, but a zinger no less!!! Thank God Mitt did not drop his stack of 3x5 cards!

October 03 2012 at 11:37 PM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply

WOW --- Obama is getting his A-- Kicked Big Time. Still blaming everyone but guess who--

October 03 2012 at 10:30 PM Report abuse -2 rate up rate down Reply

There is no doubt that Romney makes much more sense than Obama. The debate is half over and I am stunned that anybody voted for Obama....or would in the next election.

October 03 2012 at 10:20 PM Report abuse -2 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to doodlewhopper12's comment

You don't like the free handouts we get with Obama ? I love all my free stuff. I'm voting for the food stamp president.

October 03 2012 at 10:31 PM Report abuse -3 rate up rate down Reply

RomneyCare the mormon NeoCon.

October 03 2012 at 9:01 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

Surprise, surprise. The man who claimed Mitt Romney hasn't paid taxes for ten years on the Senate floor because "someone" told him that was the case, is refusing to release his own tax returns. Reid, who lives in the Ritz-Carlton in Washington D.C. has gone from middle class to being worth more than $10 million during his time in the Senate.

Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid again deflected questions Monday about releasing his tax returns, even as he continued to pound the demand for Mitt Romney to make more of his own public.

Then we have the Botox Queen say the same..

House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) pushed back hard Thursday against the notion that congressional leaders should release their tax returns, saying the standard applies only to presidential candidates.

“When I run for president of the United States, you can hold me to that standard,” Pelosi told reporters in the Capitol.

“The disclosure that we have is full and complete,” she added, noting that she's met all of the financial disclosure obligations required of Congress.

They write the laws that protect them from prison, as well as making money on insider trading..

Nancy Pelosi never read the health care bill but she sure read all the insider trading stock tips sent to her..
Nancy Pelosi Blocked Credit Card Reform While Investing Millions in Exclusive Visa Stock Offering

Former Speaker of the House–and current Minority Leader–Nancy Pelosi apparently bought $1 million to $5 million of Visa stock in one of the most sought-after and profitable initial public offerings (IPO) in American history, thwarted serious credit card reform for two years, and then watched her investment skyrocket 203%.
Her response to a reporter when asked about this was " What's your point? I did nothing wrong."

October 03 2012 at 6:51 PM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply


October 03 2012 at 6:38 PM Report abuse +6 rate up rate down Reply