Experts say that the requests may be legal. But that's not necessarily what's really worrying Internet companies.
Even if it's A-OK in the legal sphere, the publicity around the idea brings up a topic that companies like Facebook and Google (GOOG) would prefer to avoid: privacy.
In their ideal world, these companies could gather as much user data as possible without creating a backlash against their core products. But we don't live in an ideal world, do we?
Good Luck With That
Facebook has been dealing with this for years. And ironically, it's Facebook's own social network that sounds the alarm and sets off the frenzy whenever privacy issues rear their heads.
Every time the company changes its privacy settings, intrepid users blast their friends with alerts and tell them how to change their settings to protect private information.
Facebook isn't making things easier for itself. The company allows apps to ask for almost any type of information they want. For example, Zynga (ZNGA) wants access to your name, profile picture, gender, friends, and any other public information. They even want to post on my wall on my behalf. If you don't give them the rights to your information, you can't play their games. What's this world coming to?
Google has enjoyed a somewhat easier ride with privacy over the years, but it's beginning to come under attack as well.
Why It Matters to Companies
The conundrum for Facebook, Google, and any other company that collects your data, is that they use information about you to target goods, services, and advertising. If you "like" Coca-Cola on Facebook, you may find a Coke Zero ad on some of the pages you visit. Scarier yet, if you follow Coca-Cola on Google+, Google can place those ads almost anywhere you go on the Internet, since the company's advertising reach is so wide.
Knowing more about you means more focused ads, and more focused ads mean more revenue for Google and Facebook. It's in their best interest to know as much about you as they can.
Sorry, the Privacy Ship Has Already Sailed
And more and more tracking is exactly what they're doing.
Do you even know what's being tracked on your computer, smartphone, or tablet right now? Google recently got in trouble for slipping some tracking code into Apple (AAPL) devices, so you probably don't. There are cookies, widgets, and other thingamabobbers that track all kinds of information about your Internet usage and feed it back to a variety of sources.
Privacy has become so complicated online that it doesn't really exist. Unless you keep information off the web, there are probably ways someone will share it.
How Mad Do You Have to Get?
The industry has been in enough hot water over this topic that it's surprising that a solution to the privacy issue hasn't been found. Maybe there's not enough outrage, or maybe we just don't care. Until we do, Facebook, Google, and other Internet companies are going to squeeze as much information out of you as they can. It's in their best interest to do so.
Motley Fool contributor Travis Hoium does not have a position in any company mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of Coca-Cola, Apple, and Google. Motley Fool newsletter services have recommended buying shares of Coca-Cola, Apple, and Google, as well as creating a bull call spread position on Apple.
- The Rich Get Richer in Social Gaming: Zynga Buys Draw Something Vendor OMGPOP
- Mobile Payment's Sticky Side: The Hidden Cost of Ultra-Easy Buying
- Facebook Timeline and Privacy: What You Need to Know