Cost of Cable Bundling: $100 a Year for Sports, Whether You Watch or Not


Is ESPN Charging a Tax on Every American Household?The next time you find yourself bellyaching over your expanding monthly cable bill, don't blame your provider. Blame Tim Tebow! Curse LeBron James! Hate on Tiger Woods! You're a bum, A-Rod!

Even though your cable, satellite, or broadband television provider may be despised for completely legitimate reasons, when it comes to your ever-rising bill, the providers are mostly just passing along the scaling programming costs of networks. As The New York Times reports, "American television subscribers pay, on average, about $100 a year for sports programming -- no matter how many games they watch."

A lot of that goes to the NFL, which just finalized a nine-year programming extension with Fox, CBS (CBS), and Comcast's (CMCSA) NBC. The NFL's cut? Twenty-seven billion dollars, a sum so large that the Times predicts "the average cable bill will rise again soon."

Taxing Sports

When it comes to basic cable, ESPN is perhaps the biggest offender. Media tracker SNL Kagan estimates that ESPN alone sets distributors back $4.69 a month for every subscriber.

You can expect that figure to continue to inch higher, and some in the industry are more than a bit concerned. Speaking at a media conference earlier this month, Liberty Media (LMCA) CEO Greg Maffei suggested that there will come a point when ESPN's escalating fees will become a "tax on every American household."

We may already be there.

Fumbling the Handoff

Your cable provider points to Disney's (DIS) ESPN, but the original 24/7 sports network doesn't want to take the fall. See, it too is passing on the costs of larger sums of money that it has to shell out to sporting leagues with every passing year.

The only silver lining for consumers in the NFL's new deal with the major networks is that Fox, CBS, and NBC are free over-the-air channels. You can kick your pay-TV provider to the curb and get a cheap HD antenna to catch all three networks for free. Advertisers will likely pick up most of the bill, and the broadcasters will eat the rest.

However, this doesn't mean that other networks aren't paying through the nose for pigskin rights. ESPN and NFL Sunday Ticket home DIRECTV (DTV) recently inked extensions that also dramatically marked up their licensing fees.

So the next time you hear someone claim that overpaid athletes aren't your problem, show them your cable bill.

Bundling is the Bomb

I'm paying $4.69 a month for ESPN, apparently, and I don't mind. I get enough entertainment out of the sports network to make it worthwhile. Maybe you feel the same way. Maybe you don't. However, my aunt -- who doesn't know the gridiron from a baseball diamond -- can't be too happy subsidizing our sports viewing just so she can watch Mad Men on AMC.

Then again, I have no need for The Weather Channel or QVC. C-SPAN? Hallmark Channel? Please. Why can't I cherry-pick the channels that I am presumably paying for? Why do folks pay for both MSNBC and Fox News when really they will only watch one or the other?

Here is where the fingers point right back at the cable companies. They're the ones with loosely bundled packages that find couch potatoes paying for hundreds of channels, 90% of which they will never watch.

The downside to customized options, beyond the logistics of making it happen, is that cable bills wouldn't necessarily get any cheaper. If ESPN loses half of its subscribers, it would have little choice but to double its rates. These are companies with set expenses to cover. The denominator doesn't change, even if the numerator contracts.

You don't have to like it, but you can vote with your feet.

Pass Interference

No one is demanding an ESPN tax out of you. Comcast -- the country's largest cable provider -- offers a "digital economy" package that sidesteps the costly sports programming. Smaller providers have similar packages.

However, that value-priced bundle doesn't have many basic cable staples, including CNBC, FX, and Nickelodeon. If you want a regular dose of Jim Cramer, American Horror Story, or SpongeBob, you're going to have to take ESPN with that.

That could well change in the future. Whether out of economic need or libertarian inspiration, more and more "cord cutters" are cancelling their cable subscriptions and opting for streaming options. Smart televisions are making it easier to connect to Web-served programming on demand, putting consumers back in control.

"No taxation without representation" was the slogan of one revolution a couple of centuries ago. It might be time for another one, only on a much smaller scale, and a much different playing field.

Longtime Motley Fool contributor Rick Munarriz does not own shares in any of the stocks in this article, except for Disney and Liberty Media. Motley Fool newsletter services have recommended buying shares of Disney.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Intro to Retirement

Get started early planning for your long term future.

View Course »

Goal Setting

Want to succeed? Then you need goals!

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:

When they start charging for all sports; I'll then pull the plug on cable. About to now with all the commercials and programs that repeat time after time.

December 19 2011 at 11:59 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

I live in Charlote,N.C. and don't have cable. I just use the Converter Box and a Desk top antenna. This month I cancellled Roadrunner Turbo Service and saved $ 9.95 for my internet service. Heads up. Roadrunner increased the speed from 12 mb to 15 mb for regualr internet service, The turbo for 5 more MB of speed is $ 9.95.

December 19 2011 at 8:37 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

I'm in the same boat, paying DirectTV about 100/month with DVR service, all that to watch the 12 channels I care about. Been with them since 1998. No cable out here in the "woods". However, that will be coming to an end soon, they have priced themselves out of my house, we CAN AND WILL do WITHOUT THEM.

December 19 2011 at 7:47 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Canada has ala carte channels, pay only for what you want to watch....
I cut the cable years ago, I have a deep fringe antenna, I receive local and
far away channels, channels I was surprised that were on the air for free.
Such As, 24 hour oldies movies, 8 different PBS channels, weather, news, sports
I receive 82 channels of watchable TV...I live NW of downtown atlanta in the foothills
of the applachian mountains. You'd be surprised what you can receive if you would
get a good deep fringe antenna...just rotate it...all sorts of channels come up.

December 18 2011 at 5:43 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

I would like to pick just the channels I like to watch. Like the Military, news, local channels, and a few others. I do not watch the ESPN or any sport channels and hate paying fo them. My cable bill is 142.00 per month, I have Phone, Internet and bundled cable.

December 18 2011 at 4:36 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

I'll take the hit on the sports but I'd like to see what the Home Shopping Network and the like cost me. I just wish the sports channels carried more rugby matches.

December 18 2011 at 4:31 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Jeff Burns

Yeah, my cable bill is sitting at $90 with no premium anything... 80% is channels I don't watch. I've been finding it is cheaper just to pay for the programs I like ala carte from Amazon VOD, or watch them via Hulu, or whatever and catch them on a 24 hour delay. At that point bypassing the network for the most part. Cable's days are quite numbered, as things go digital. With that said, the spouse still won't let me kill the cable bill though. She's addicted to be able to surf 100's of channels of nothing on, because *something* might come on... Although getting Google TV which seamlessly switches between Online and broadcast content is starting to make inroads for killing our cable bill...

December 18 2011 at 12:45 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

4 great comments , I guess most are sleeping in on this Saturday morn , but they will wake up soon and then it will begin. Have a great day and holiday.

December 17 2011 at 4:01 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

Re: "You can kick your pay-TV provider to the curb and get a cheap HD antenna to catch all three networks for free".

I can? I'd have to have a 500 foot tall antenna to pickup any of those stations. There simply are no "over the air" stations available at my home. There are actually large mountains between me and any of their transmitters. I'd love to go to the "over the air" stations. There are none here.

December 17 2011 at 3:53 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply

Al-A-Carte cable is the only fair thing to do.

December 17 2011 at 3:16 AM Report abuse +4 rate up rate down Reply