Get the latest in savings. Like us on Facebook.

Holiday Travel on a Budget

Posted 1:30PM 12/02/11 Savings Experiment, Travel Industry |
Savings Experiment: Holiday Travel

Whether you're spending the holidays with family or getting away from everything (and everyone), there are several factors to weigh when traveling this season.

Boy Are My Arms Tired

As airline tickets and gas prices soar, it can be difficult to gauge whether it's more economical to fly or drive. Luckily, Befrugal.com's "Fly or Drive Calculator" helps you calculate hidden costs, like overnight pit stops or time spent commuting to the airport.

If you're driving, AAA, Costco, and Travelmath all offer fuel calculators, so you can figure out about how much gas will run, before you run out of it. According to Mint, a personal finance application, any drive that takes less than four hours is a better budgetary bet than flying.

In addition to the dollar value, there are other elements to factor in, like time. The New York Times has a calculator to help you assess how much your time is worth to you.

How to save on holiday travelOf course, there are emotional costs, which only you will be able to weigh. Does sitting on the road in bumper-to-bumper conditions make you want to hurl yourself into oncoming traffic? If you fly, are you willing to deal with the possibility of cancelled flights, long security lines, and baggage premiums? If you have kids, you'll also want to factor in how well your children behave in the car versus on a plane. (This may also be an issue with pets, spouses, and in-laws.)

Public Transportation

Most of the world takes the train for short and long trips. Amtrak offers different levels of trains and some routes include sleeper cars. Be mindful that ticket prices go up, sometimes outrageously, closer to the dates of travel. However, if you book in advance, you can find great deals.

Trains offer a surprising amount of amenities. Amtrak is also currently upgrading to include wireless on certain routes, like along its Northeast Corridor. Even the standard trains provide spacious seats, bathrooms, and electric outlets, so you don't have to worry about your computer dying. Of course, you may grow weary of the food selection or being trapped indoors. Still, it's a fantastic alternative to driving, especially if you prefer to use travel time to catch up on reading a book (or writing one).

Then there's the bus, which in recent years has seen a resurgence in popularity due to rising costs of planes, trains, and automobiles. (Not to be confused with the old Steven Martin and John Candy movie.) Bolt and Megabus sometimes offer deals as cheap as a $1 a ride (you read that correctly!).

Check your route, as there may be a plethora of options. Greyhound can get you just about anywhere, but it can be surprisingly expensive on smaller routes between major cities, like Boston, Washington, DC, and New York. It's worth comparing the cost of Greyhound to the Chinatown buses, Megabus, DC2NY, and Bolt. There are also "luxurious" bus lines, like Vamoose, which may be more expensive but have less competition for seats. Most importantly, always check the individual companies' driving records! Google is a beautiful tool.

Getting There Is Half the Battle

Once you've decided on a mode of transportation, don't forget to calculate the price of lodging, food, sundries, and, most importantly, fun. The Professional Hobo enables you to get some idea of how much each day might cost you. After you've done the math, you may really be in need of a vacation. When the time comes, the most objectively important thing to do, no matter what happens, is to enjoy the trip.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

219 Comments

Filter by:
annyperl

Well, it's also possible to buy budget travel package. I guess all travel agencies (http://www.pissedconsumer.com/consumer-reviews/travel.html) offer such option. Certainly, such travels don't guarantee great comfort, but still they are worth trying

December 14 2011 at 11:01 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Thomas Jones

I'm assuming that when they say "any drive that takes less than four hours is a better budgetary bet than flying", they're referring to normal, non-holiday drive time. We see family on the holidays. It's only a 120mi. drive - a drive that normally takes a shade over two hours to complete, but can take well over four hours during holiday travel days.

December 09 2011 at 7:29 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
myvonne

What a stupid article. You didn't answer the question you asked in the headline. duh

December 07 2011 at 5:04 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
cbkqmom

I have driven from VA to WA twice, WA to VA, and many trips between VA and GA. The drive across the country is awesome, and I'll do it again because I love it.
I refuse to get on a plane anymore if I can help it. Airlines love money, not their customers. Charge an arm and a leg, with no refunds?! My kids having to go through a patdown?! Yeah, this mom traveling with 4 kids, all under the age of 8 is just SUCH a terror threat >.>
The TSA treats you like cattle, wrinkling their noses at you like they are disgusted with the fact that you exist. Now they aren't satisfied with the current level of humiliation that they put us through, oh no...now you have to go through a full body scanner. I have said it before..no one is ever going to convince me that those TSA agents aren't taking cell pics and/or laughing at people's scans.
I went to get on a flight in Spain, and went to remove my shoes. ONLY Americans do that. That was very embarrassing. However, the security people were really nice, and smiled. When is the last time you saw a TSA agent smile?
Bottom line, I would rather drive, (even if I hated it)..than be stripped of my rights just because I want to fly on a stupid plane in my own country.

The TSA is NOT needed. I bet if we looked at how much those people cost, plus all the scanners etc....we would find that putting 2 armed air wardens on every flight would cost much less.

December 07 2011 at 3:59 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
thanksandpraise

driving cannot be beaten. if people drive there would be no need to strip search a 78 year old woman and the dreadful TSA would vanish. drive america the scenery is just amazing and the food is just great, no crackers and peanuts and soda

December 07 2011 at 2:47 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to thanksandpraise's comment
cbkqmom

Yep, I drive whenever possible... the only time I get on a plane is if I am flying overseas.

December 07 2011 at 3:39 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Ben

The calculation is mainly how long you will stay where your are going. It usually costs more than the gas to drive, including motel costs, restaurants, etc. Flying gets you there faster, but you have to rent a car. Visiting my daughter 2700 miles away means driving if we will be there over a month. Besides the airlines treat you like dirt anymore unless you are in the elite frequent flyer classes. If you are flying to London in Business or First class. or are an elite flyer - no problem. Going into regional airports or traveling economy - forget about it. I could give you stories, but space doesn't permit/

December 07 2011 at 2:36 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
kjasperkc

No more flying. Driving is the only way we travel now. Driving is far less stressful.

December 07 2011 at 1:42 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to kjasperkc's comment
laptop603

Where did you go?

December 07 2011 at 2:41 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
petrini1

Unless I'm traveling overseas, I will almost always drive. Flying has become an inconvenient, dehumanizing, and expensive experience. Customer service on the airlines and in the airports is atrocious. Security measures are degrading and downright silly.

It's nearly always cheaper to drive, even if it takes several days and I have to factor in the cost of hotels. I can leave when it's convenient for me. I don't have to take off my shoes unless I feel like it. And I can take as much luggage as I can fit in the car -- without being charged extra -- and fill it with more than 3 ounces of shampoo. I also like being able to stop if I want to, or to take a spur-of-the-minute detour if I suddenly hear of an interesting side trip.

December 07 2011 at 1:31 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to petrini1's comment
cbkqmom

And you won't lose hundreds of dollars if you aren't able to leave when you had planned.

December 07 2011 at 3:41 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
siscosdad

Drive....which will be more peaceful and less invasive, cheaper, and will piss off TSA and Homeleand Security. They're uselesss anyway, and a burden on the taxpayers.

December 07 2011 at 1:21 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
mrmyfld1

what a joke....bottom line, what do you value....and how much do u want to spend,

Skip the so called calculators....use common sense

December 07 2011 at 12:25 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Are you a
Savings Expert?

If so, send us your idea and we'll try to include it in an upcoming Savings Experiment

Create a tip