Will Congress Cure the Problems with Health Care FSAs?

healthcare costsYou practically have to be an accountant to manage your family's health care these days. The good news is, some lawmakers seem to recognize this and are working toward changes to one program that should be well received by employers, employees and doctors alike.

The Medical Flexible Spending Improvement Act (S. 1404) was introduced in the Senate and would allow employees to withdraw and pay taxes on any remaining funds in their flexible spending accounts at the end of the year, removing the controversial "use it or lose it" issue that has left many people frantically trying to fit in dental visits or pick up a pair of eyeglasses to spend down their FSA's in December. One couple even squeezed in colonoscopies on Christmas Eve.

Savvy and organized consumers seem to make good use of their FSAs throughout the year, but it's widely agreed some logical adjustments need to be made to how they are regulated. First, it can be difficult to guess in advance how much money it will make sense to set aside for health care in a given year, and there's currently no option to roll over funds into the next.

"It is time to modernize FSAs to eliminate the burdensome 'use it or lose it' rule," Sen. Ben Cardin (D-Md.) said. "It is both fair and sound health policy to allow FSA participants to cash-out remaining funds at the end of the plan year rather than forfeiting the balance to their employer." The advocacy group Save Flexible Spending Plans is encouraging Americans to "remind Congress flexible spending accounts are part of the solution, not part of the problem."

A Good Way to Prepare for Medical Expenses

Fear of losing the FSA money definitely weighs on the choices of Cathy Davenport of Blakeslee Pa., the mother of two teenage girls. She started using an FSA when her girls needed braces. Now, she finds it's good for glasses and contacts, but she notes: "I always run out of funds in July, because I am scared of losing the money." Removing the "use it or lose it" factor would alleviate this common, understandable concern.

Diedre Ayers of Maplewood N.J., the highly-organized working mother of a 2-year-old son, is a huge proponent of FSAs. She reviews her annual medical expenses when open-enrollment time rolls around and looks forward to signing up for what she describes as "a pre-tax savings account that I don't even have to worry about." That annual routine more than paid off during her pregnancy, as well as when they made a recent trip to the emergency room with their son -- two significant medical events that, even with the best insurance, could have really thrown off their monthly expenses. Instead: "I just pull out my FSA Visa card for the out-of-pocket costs and I know the money is there." She deducts $3,000 to $5,000 annually from her paycheck into her FSA.

One variable viewed as a potential upcoming problem is the $2,500 cap, which will kick in beginning in 2013 as part of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. Employee Benefit News contributing editor Christy Yaccarino makes a compelling case the cap is too low, pointing out that employees will be stuck with substantial out-of-pocket expenses if they get trapped between exceeding the cap and not reaching out-of-pocket spending maximums.

Prescription Rule Is a 'Cure' Worse Than the Problem

Also being revisited is the provision requiring a prescription for buying over-the-counter medicine with FSA accounts. Intended to prevent consumers from unnecessarily stocking up on the likes of aspirin and ibuprofen to deplete their FSA accounts, it instead sent patients flocking to doctors offices just to get a piece of paper. Understandably, that didn't go over well with many physicians, especially when you consider the math on the doctor's side. Dr. Matthew Mintz gives an eye-opening account, explaining that procedures get reimbursed, while time-consuming but less tangible tasks like talking to patients, filling out forms, etc., do not. Moreover, physicians take on liability every time they write a prescription. Doctors simply aren't being compensated to reflect new realities. Even they need to be accountants these days.

Dr. Richard Barron, an internist in a practice with more than 8,000 patients, took on the task, conducting a year-long study to evaluate just how doctors are allocating their time during their roughly 50- to 60-hour work weeks. The numbers tell the story regarding what's keeping doctors so busy in primary care:

On an average work day, each primary care provider in his practice, reportedly:

• Saw 18.1 patients
• Handled 23.7 phone calls
• Answered 16.8 emails
• Issued 12.1 prescription refills (above and beyond those issued during patient visits).

At least patients appear to appreciate physicians' efforts, even if insurance companies haven't adjusted the way they compensate them. The Deloitte 2011 Survey of Health Care Consumers in the United States indicates just 38% of consumers feel they received value for money spent on health insurance, but fully 61% feel they received excellent or good value on physician or specialist services. It appears our primary issues with primary care really are on the insurance side and we're a wreck about them. The same study soberly reports that 23% of consumers say they feel confident their household is financially prepared to handle future health care costs, holding close to the 24% levels observed in 2010 and 2009. That's not progress.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Timing Your Spending

How to pay less by changing when you purchase.

View Course »

How to Buy a Car

How to get the best deal and buy a car with confidence.

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:

how about also allowing you to increase the FSA deduction during the year if your "open enrollment" estimate comes up short?

July 31 2011 at 6:00 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to bassfish4's comment

I like this idea ... a mid-year adjustment even if the terms are slightly revised. Good call.

August 01 2011 at 12:30 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

My wife and I had four operations. Two on back, one knee replacement , and one shoulder replacement. Our Surgeon visited us nearly every day while in the hospital. We never needed any medical attention by doctors during the three to four days in the hospital. The hospital doctors submited large charges to Medicare, and we never saw the doctors.
Two cases wre submitted to Medicare and were ignored. They said it was common practice for doctors to go by and check our file and not be seen. Some charges were for extensive physical exams. I reported two cases to our Representative and received no help, Do you know anyone who would invesitgate an obvious fraud?

July 30 2011 at 3:15 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
3 replies to jreaganiii's comment

My wife and I have had four cases of medicare fraud committeed by Hospital doctors. We had four operations two on back, one knee replacement, and one shoulder replacement. Estremely large charges were submitted by the doctors to medicare. We never saw the doctors and they were not needed. The surgeons all visited us nearly every day.

July 30 2011 at 3:06 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mad Dog

Use Your FSA to buy medical maryjane then you won't care! LOL

July 30 2011 at 7:57 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

One big problem with flexible medical spending accounts is that they are not provided to all; only the higher earners participate, which equates to yet another tax loop hole.

July 30 2011 at 4:11 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

One big problem with HSAs or FSAs is the fact that the insurance companies still set the rates of each and every procedure or doctor's visit, therefore these do not create any competition for those healthcare dollars. If I need a colonoscopy, and I have to pay for it as part of my deductible, then the FSA is great as far as that I can pay with untaxed dollars. However, I cannot negotiate a price with a given doctor for the colonoscopy, because my insurance company has already set the rate, and I must use a doctor that accepts my insurance. Because of this, doctors and insurance companies still need to fill out all types of insurance forms and in most cases, the doctors must wait a few months for payment. What we need to do is allow patients to find their own care, and then submit the payment receipts to their insurance companies for credit toward their deductible. By doing this, doctors would have to compete for the business, regardless of one's insurance, but they would get paid at the time service is rendered. They would also be able to then skip all the insurance forms that normally must be processed adding a substantial amount to their costs.

July 30 2011 at 1:58 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

I don't think Congress will cure or fix any problems for the American people, they are too busy finding every way possible to stuff even more of our money in their pockets these are the greediest ever seen in the stately halls of Congress and combined with a know nothing big spending bill pusher President like Obimbo we are caught in
a cascade of stupidly greedy pigs at the public trough.

July 29 2011 at 11:51 PM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply

OBAMA CARE IS OUT OF HERE IN 2012 !!!!!!! AMEN !!!!!!!.

July 29 2011 at 10:26 PM Report abuse +4 rate up rate down Reply

Congress could not fix the time of day All they know how to do is take care of their rich friends and themselfs. We should kick them all out and start all over again.

July 29 2011 at 8:22 PM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply

I got my doubts if the moderate conservatives can compromise with the Tea Baggers

July 29 2011 at 7:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply