Mantegna, 63, could probably afford to splurge. He plays a big-shot FBI profiler on the CBS show Criminal Minds, and has forged a second career in voice work. Mantegna began reading books on tape in 1984 and has put the words in Fat Tony's mafioso mouth on The Simpsons since 1991. In Disney/Pixar's Cars 2, he said, he has reached the top of the animated film ladder -- as a bitter Gremlin who's trying to off the hero, Lightning McQueen.
The actor is presumably set. Yet he is set in his cautious ways.
"I come from a background where my father never had a checkbook or a credit card," he told The Price of Fame. "If he didn't have cash, we didn't get it. So I kind of live my life that way. That might be a little extreme but at least if you're someone in that part of the ballpark, you're not going to be taken by surprise in the worst scenario."
Reminded that he has had a series-TV paycheck since 2007, he replied, "Adjust accordingly. When it's manna from heaven, you eat a little better than when it's a famine."
Splurging Rarely, and Focusing on What He Does Best
Getting cast in Cars 2 was a happy accident for Mantegna, an auto buff with vintage tastes. Back in leaner times -- that would be Chicago in 1967 -- he bought a 1947 Buick for $225. For five years, he used it to drive around his rock band, the Apocryphals. Then, in 1972 he stored it in a friend's Indiana barn and forgot about it. Thirty years later, the friend called to say he was moving, and told Mantegna he had to fetch his old rust bucket.
It's an apparent rare splurge for Mantegna, who has appeared in more than 80 films and 15 TV series. "I would have friends who would get a TV pilot and would spend the money as if the series had been on for five years," he explained.
Many of us could take a cue from his Hollywood story. Mantegna has made a significant chunk of his income by being typecast as a gangster, including Joey Zasa in The Godfather: Part III. "People will always pigeonhole people according to their strength," he said. "It's really fine. I've never been first on the list to play Swedish sea captains and rightly so."
He has, however, played Dean Martin (The Rat Pack), a womanizing dentist (Compromising Positions) and a slew of parts for playwright, screenwriter and director David Mamet. Mantegna branched out as a writer, producer and director, too. It all adds up to a living. Why toss it away by living too large? He's got enough drama onscreen.
"I still try to be conservative about it all," he said.