Oil and Food Prices Keep Rising: Should the Fed Raise Interest RatesWith oil prices 14% higher in the last week, up $12 a barrel to around $97, consumers are poised to pay more at the pumps even as Libya's main oil company, Arabian Gulf Oil Co., resumes exports from rebel-controlled areas that account for a quarter of Libya's supply, according to The Wall Street Journal. Even though Libya accounts for a mere 0.5% of U.S. oil imports, those rising crude prices are percolating through the U.S. economy, leading many to wonder: Should the Fed change its course and raise interest rates to control prices?

Nobody likes higher prices, but the answer is still "no."

Raising interest rates has risks as well as benefits. One risk is that with the national debt at $14.1 trillion, more expensive debt service due to higher rates could crowd out other government spending -- thus cutting into economic growth. And higher rates would do little to lower those spiking prices because people will need food and oil regardless of how high interest rates get. And the Fed has limited ability to influence the global markets that set their prices.

The only reason the Fed would raise rates is if U.S. wages start to rise faster than its 2% inflation target. And with unit labor costs down 1.5% in the final quarter of 2010, median family income down 8.1% in the last decade and with 9% unemployment and 76% capacity utilization (below the 81% long-term average), there is no danger of workers getting together anytime soon to demand and get higher wages. So with the threat of higher labor costs quite low, the Fed will likely stand pat on rates until the unemployment rate drops closer to 5%.

Gold Bugs Always Want to Blame the Fed

As emotionally frustrating as it is for consumers to pay more for gasoline, food and clothing, those items account for a mere 25% of the typical household budget. But those prices are certainly going up -- partially because of higher oil prices. As I wrote in a DailyFinance article last week, higher oil prices affect every producer of goods that uses oil as a raw material -- such as plastics -- and any retailer that pays to transport goods or people, like airlines. With gasoline prices up 18 cents a gallon in the last month, that pain at the pump is real.

Some critics blame higher prices on the Fed's policies. As I experienced most recently during a CNBC sparring session last Thursday, the standard response of the gold bugs to food and energy inflation is that it's caused by the Fed debasing the dollar with low interest rates, out-of-control federal debt and record budget deficits. But Fed actions have little impact on commodity prices. Oil is traded on the global market, and worldwide supply and demand sets prices. It's worth pointing out that the global market tends to impose a growth tax of its own -- reducing U.S. GDP growth by 0.5% for every $10 increase in oil prices.

The one area where the Fed is contributing to the rise of oil prices is by making near-zero interest rate loans available to traders who are betting on fear: specifically, fear of more significant oil production cuts in the future.

I wrote about this issue on DailyFinance's sister site, BloggingStocks, back in 2008 when oil hit a record $147 a barrel. At that time, the Commodities Futures Trading Commission found that traders who were borrowing money to buy oil futures and sell the dollar short accounted for 81% of trading volume. I wouldn't be surprised if such trading was a major factor in the recent oil price spike.

If the Fed were to raise rates now, there's little question that it would slow the nascent economic recovery. The U.S. has borrowed $14.1 trillion and higher interest rates would mean higher payments on that debt. Every dollar diverted to paying higher interest expenses is a dollar diverted away from more productive uses such as investments to boost the economy. The Fed will take that risk only if it believes inflationary expectations are taking hold in the minds of investors due to long-term wage increases.

Higher Pay for Workers Isn't Likely

With conservative state governments around the country opening up new fronts in the war against the American worker by moving to eliminate unions, there's no danger of U.S. wages rising in the foreseeable future. Instead, expect to see those bellowing elephants use their corporate-cash-filled trunks to break the unions, along with the hopes of workers for a reversal in the decade-long trend of lower pay and higher prices. (It's no coincidence that Koch Industries is a major contributor to Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, who is in the midst of a pitched battle to end collective bargaining for most state employees.)

Meanwhile, the Fed won't raise rates. Nor should it.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Introduction to Retirement Funds

Target date funds help you maintain a long term portfolio.

View Course »

How to Avoid Financial Scams

Avoid getting duped by financial scams.

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum


Filter by:


March 01 2011 at 4:20 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

Cohan lives in a fairy tale world where, "Oil is traded on the global market, and worldwide supply and demand sets prices", yet printing a massive amount of dollars has no bearing on demand.

March 01 2011 at 3:58 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

Nothing of the financial meltdown can ever be truly fixed until the Fed is abolished. End of story.

March 01 2011 at 1:30 PM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

our government rewards debt via the tax code and punishes savings via the tax code. it's time for the tax code and social engineering by congress to GO!

March 01 2011 at 7:35 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

we need the dollar based on gold...please....we need The Fed audited....please...and we need savings accounts and excellent interest rates...please!

March 01 2011 at 7:33 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

The government uses the concept of "substitution" to arrive at low core inflation numbers. Namely, if the price of one item goes up, consumers could substitute a similar product. To actually experience the official inflation numbers a consumer would need to comparasion shop for the lowest priced item which could substitute for what they really want.

March 01 2011 at 5:47 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply

The oil companies are useing libya as another cheap trick to make billions in profits. How can gas prices keep going up when the more costly oile isn't even here yet? PRICE GOUGING IDIOTS AND OUR GOVERNMENT DOES NOTHING> WHY????????? Because big oil finances their campaigns thats why. 0.5% of our oil but yet we have to pay for oil that is still in the ground. Hopw about increasing our out put and screw the ********?

February 28 2011 at 3:46 PM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply

The only thing good for the Federal Reserve is a good NUKE dropped on the center of their fvking building!!!!

February 28 2011 at 2:45 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to dang6510's comment

here, here....same for Somalia!

March 01 2011 at 7:34 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

but it can't happen here??? think from an old alice cooper song. a true story. used to be in the metals biz, primary, secondary and scrap. was visting a secondary brass ingot maker about 1985. guess what they were melting dump truck
load after another in to their furnaces--MEXICAN PESO'S--the intrinsic value of
mostly zinc content and a tad of copper made these coins worth considerably more as melt feed than buying a 1,000,000 peso loaf of bread. we are getting close on some of our own coinage. if the copper and tin content had not been drastically reduced years ago, the whole world would be melting u. s. coins. may not be legal here, but try to enforce in taiwan, korea, india, etc..

February 28 2011 at 2:42 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply

get out your chopsticks and rice bowls and welcome to japan. they already found out essentially zero interest rates do not work. other non-sensical part of this article is just the premise the fed can do something. the fed can only do what they have been doing--keeping financial borrowing costs to near zero for the big players. the prayer is the free money at the window and basically free money via consumer deposits--since they do not pay jack--might eventually pull the financials out of the dumper. if interest rates move up, it will be inspired by external forces. what happens when the world doesn't want a short term u. s. bond at .27%? we know what happens.

February 28 2011 at 2:30 PM Report abuse +4 rate up rate down Reply