How a Credit Card Balance Transfer Can Improve Your Credit Score

Lynette Khalfani-Cox logoRight before and after the holidays you'll probably get a lot of bank offers to transfer credit-card balances from one account to another. If you see balance transfers as an opportunity to go on a shopping spree, chances are you haven't quite learned how to manage credit and debt wisely, and that balance transfer deal is simply going to lead you into financial trouble.

But does that mean that balance transfers are always bad ideas for everyone? Absolutely not.In fact, many people can use a balance transfer strategically, to save money and to boost their credit rating.

Let me explain how.

To raise your credit scores, it's always best to pay down debt, as opposed to shifting it around. However, for most people trying to boost their credit rating, it's not always possible to instantly pay off all their credit card debt.

So what can you do in that case? You can shift debt around – or increase your available credit – in order to strategically lower your credit card utilization rate.

A big chunk of your FICO credit score – 30%, to be exact – is based on the amount of credit card debt you're carrying vs. your overall credit card limits. This ratio is known as your "credit utilization rate."

For example, let's say your creditors have extended to you a total of $15,000 in available credit on all your cards. If you've charged $10,000 on those cards, you've used up two-thirds of your available credit and your credit utilization rate is 67% – not good.

What is the "Ideal" Credit Utilization Rate?

To increase your credit scores, it's imperative that you slash your credit utilization ratios. No one knows the precise magic number when it comes to credit utilizations rates; FICO doesn't reveal the exact "ideal" credit utilization rate.

However, we do know that higher credit utilizations rates generally translate into lower FICO scores. And statistically speaking, those with lower credit utilization rates have higher FICO scores.

Therefore, conventional wisdom is that it's best to keep your credit utilization rates at a maximum of 25% or so for a higher FICO score. (If you haven't seen your FICO score lately, read this article on how to get your FICO score free).

But even if you maintain zero credit card debt, by paying off your credit card bills in full each month, realize that you still may not have a 0% credit utilization rate simply because of three timing factors:
  • the date when you pay your bills,
  • the date when your creditor reports your payment history to the credit bureaus;
  • the date that your credit report is pulled to generate a credit score

Besides, you need not worry about having a 0% credit utilization rate simply because, believe it or not, individuals with a 0% credit utilization rate actually have lower credit scores – an average credit score of just 678, versus average credit scores of 745 for those with credit utilization rates ranging from 1% to 10%, according to data from CreditKarma.com, which analyzed a random sample of 70,000 credit scores.

How is it possible that those with a 0% credit utilization rate have average credit scores of only 678 points? CreditKarma.com suggests a few likely causes.

First, it's possible that individuals with a 0% credit utilization rate have no credit cards at all. This could actually hurt their credit rating, because 10% of your credit score is based on the mix of credit that is contained in your credit files. Having a credit card, along with different forms of credit, shows that you can responsibly manage various types of credit simultaneously.

Another plausible reason for the lower scores among those with a 0% credit utilization rate is that those individuals never use their credit cards at all. That's another reason to regularly use your credit cards, even if only occasionally, just to keep them active.

If you don't have the money to pay down debt, here are two strategies to lower your credit card utilization rates:

Shift Balances From One Card to Another Existing Card

Shifting debt from one credit card to another is more art than science, but done properly, it can boost your credit scores and also save you lots of money (particularly if you're taking debt from one card with a higher interest rate and putting it on a card with a lower interest rate).

The key here is to minimize the debt you're carrying on a card that has a high credit utilization and transfer that debt onto a credit card with a zero balance or a low balance.

For example, assume you have two credit cards, and each has a $5,000 credit limit. If one card has $2,500 in charges, and the other card has a balance of $500, your current credit utilization rate is 30% ($3,000 owed divided by your $10,000 overall credit limit).

You may be able to positively impact your credit scores, however, if you spread out some of that $2,500 in credit card debt from the first card. By shifting $1,000 of that balance onto the other card, your overall credit utilization rate will still be the same: 30%.

However, the credit utilization rate for the first card will drop from 50% to 30%. Meanwhile, the second card will also have a new credit utilization ratio of 30%.

Open a New Credit Card Account

Opening a new credit card account can also lower your overall credit utilization ratio, even if you don't charge anything on that new credit card.

Applying for the new card will generate an inquiry on your credit report, which can definitely impact your credit score. However, having that additional line of credit can more than make up for any hit to your credit that results from the credit inquiry.

After all, your credit utilization ratio comprises 30% of your credit score, and inquiries only account for 10% of your score. (Starting in 2011, however, inquiries will carry more weight under some credit scoring systems. As I explained recently in a WalletPop column on upcoming changes to the world of credit scoring, the VantageScore will count inquiries as 30% of your overall credit score).

Using the same example above, assume you have those two credit cards with a total of $10,000 in available credit, and $3,000 in charges made, for a current credit utilization rate of 30%.

If you open a new credit card account with a $5,000 credit limit, now your overall credit utilization rate drops to just 20% because you've charged $3,000 and you have a grand total of $15,000 in available credit across three different cards.

You could also evenly distribute the amount owed on each card, putting $1,000 each card, so that each card would have a 20% credit utilization rate. This could potentially improve your credit scores because you would lower your credit utilization rate on each individual card from either 50% (as in the first example above) or 30% (as in the second example).

Again, paying off credit card debt is the sure-fire way of raising your credit scores. But when that's not possible, adjusting the balances can help. The best way to determine the effectiveness of shifting around balances is to monitor your credit. That way, you'll see the impact that your actions have on your credit standing.

A few caveats on balance transfers that involve opening a new card:
  • Do comparison shop for the best deal on credit card offers (Bankrate.com, LowCards.com or CreditCards.com can help you shop around)
  • Do look at the overall economics of any deal to make sure a balance transfer makes financial sense, after taking into account any fees charged
  • Don't close your old accounts; that could hurt your credit rating
  • Don't open a rash of new cards; just one is fine

So the bottom line is this: when initiating a balance transfer, you want to do it the right way. And having one new account with a low or very competitive interest rate can not only save you big bucks, it can also help improve your credit rating.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Economics 101

Intro to economics. But fun.

View Course »

How Financial Planners go Grocery Shopping

Learn to shop smart and save.

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

3 Comments

Filter by:
Michael Germanovsky

Now that you know importance of credit utilization ratio, and how you should spread your balance between several credit cards, consider this - doing a balance transfer means opening a new credit card, which in turn means that prospective banks will run your credit history. Don't go applying to a lot of credit cards just because you want to spread the balance. Your applications may be denied and too many hard inquiries on your credit report may lower your credit score as much as 10%. Instead, see if you can spread the balance between your existing credit card and a new one; or better yet, see if you qualify for a credit card with a zero interest period of 12 month. Statistically, paying down your debt without paying your interest for 12 month, cuts your overall repayment period by half. Consider this, if you maxed out your $5,000 credit limit, a smart move would be to shift this balance on a zero interest card, pay $291.66 per month and therefore shave off $3500 off the principal of your debt, before the interest kicks in. At that time you will only owe $1500 and will be exactly at good credit utilization ratio of 30%. Also, a good idea to compare offers with a Balance Transfer Calculator available at sites like Credit-Land.com

July 20 2012 at 12:13 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Dereck

Do yourself a "HUGE FAVOR" and carefully read this:

The 21st Century Act: Final Amendments to Regulation CC Section:
"Prohibits" reimbursement of Credit, Loan, and Finance Balances to a "Bank Entity" leaving only "Nonbank Consumers" able to receive reimbursement, as specified on Pages 85 and 86.

The 21st Century Act states on pg. 85 and 86 that "Only Nonbank Consumers can suffer losses and File for
Re-credit or Re-claim on any Accounts under the Federal Reserve System" also “Any Second or Third Party Presenters utilizing a Banks Documentation, Contracts and/or Agreements to seek Claims shall be considered to be that Bank under the Rules and Regulations”, the Expanded Definitions also includes Credit Cards and Home Equity Lines of Credit.
Also on Pages 100 and 101 "In any Financial Claims the Indemifying Bank (Parent Bank) must be Identified".

(Left-Click to Search Link)
21st Century Act: Final Amendments to Regulation CC http://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/press/bcreg/2004/20040726/attachment.pdf

This Federal Law signed January 1, 2006 makes it "Fraudulent" and therefore "Illegal" for the 3 Major Personal Credit Reporting Agencies: Equifax, Experian, and TrasUnion to allow the Banks and the Banks "Third Party Presenters" to place any claim of "Negative" or "Potentially Negative" Accounts on your Personal Credit Based upon the fact that they have no "Legal Grounds or Claim" to the Money.

This is an "Unfair Practice" that diminishes our Financial ability to support ourselves and adversely affects our ability to gain work in many areas which breaks "Antitrust Laws".

These Rules also back claims of: "Aiding and Abetting" Racketeering and Extortion (of Finance Accounts and Personal Credit Reports), Pandering (of Credit and Loan Accounts, and Conspiracy to wit), Theft, Fraud, Federal Mail Fraud, and Telephone Harassment. Also "Threatening of the U.S. Financial Infrastructure", which is a "Capital Crime".

In order to engage the Federal Trade Commission to act against this injustice we must File many Claims, as these Reports must be Filed by a large number of people in order for the Federal Trade Commission to pursue
"Legal Action".

(Left -Click to engage Email Address)

antitrust@ftc.gov

This is way easier than "Occupying Wall Street"!

March 11 2012 at 4:55 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Carol

While I was looking for a credit report site, my firend told me about a site, that offer:

- 100% Free 3 in 1 Credit Report
- Credit Monitoring
- Fraud Protection

All in one...

I tried it and I'm so satisfied with them.I just wanted to recommend you that site:

---www.CreditReportFrees.info---

January 12 2012 at 5:28 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply