Target Boycott Expands Amid Confusion About Protest Goals

×
Late Thursday, MoveOn.org announced plans to escalate its ongoing protest against Target, America's second-largest retailer. In an e-mail to supporters, the group described its new initiatives, "including skywriting above Target's headquarters, viral videos from angry customers, and live events outside stores around the country." It also plans to give the company an online petition with more than 200,000 signatories who promise to boycott the store "until it stops spending money on elections."

Why Is Everyone Mad at Target?

There seems to be confusion over what, exactly, landed Target in the doghouse. In an interview on Friday, Ilyse Hogue -- MoveOn's director of political action and the author of the emails -- stressed that her organization and the petition's signatories are focused on the question of Target's political contributions: "Target dramatically miscalculated the outrage of their customers when they tried to buy this election." In other words, Hogue believes that Target shouldn't make any political contributions at all.

On the other hand, most protesters are incensed by the specific politician that Target's money will help fund. The company gave $150,000 to MN Forward, a pro-business, pro-education political action group that is backing Minnesota state senator Tom Emmer for governor of Minnesota. While Emmer's economic priorities aren't terribly controversial, his social policies are a different matter: The senator has openly expressed his opposition to same-sex marriage, and he previously met with Bradlee Dean, the leader of a group that violently opposes homosexuality.



The link between Target's political contribution and Emmer's homophobic statements quickly led to allegations that the retailer was homophobic, or that it didn't care about its gay customers and employees. Before long, a Facebook group, "Boycott Target Until They Cease Funding Anti-Gay Politics" emerged; it currently has more than 46,000 members. Meanwhile, a Minnesota grandmother's video of her protest at the store drew over a quarter of a million views on YouTube. And gay rights groups, including the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) and Out Front Minnesota were quick to protest the company's decision to support an anti-gay candidate.

Sending a Mixed Message

It isn't hard to see why there is confusion over Target's main crime: MoveOn's initial communication was firmly focused on Emmer's unpopular policies. The original e-mail began by stating "Target just gave a huge contribution to an anti-gay, anti-immigrant, anti-progressive candidate for governor in Minnesota," and went on to characterize Emmer as "a far-right Republican who supports Arizona's draconian immigration law, wants to abolish the minimum wage and even gave money to a fringe group that condoned the execution of gay people."

On Friday, Hogue stated that "Our protest over this is centered on Target's attempt to sway an election. It just so happens that the political candidate that they chose to support endorses a far-right social agenda, but the principle is still the same." Beginning with its Thursday afternoon e-mail, MoveOn narrowed its message: the group's follow-up e-mails and press releases have downplayed Emmer's politics, characterizing him only as an "anti-gay, anti-immigration candidate."

Even so, confusion still persists. This disconnect among protesters was evident in MoveOn's second e-mail, which stated that "Instead of apologizing, Target CEO Gregg Steinhafel apparently emailed Target employees and defended the donation as focused on 'business objectives.'" However, by mid-afternoon on Thursday, Steinhafel had issued an apology to his employees, stating that "our decision affected many of you in a way I did not anticipate, and for that I am genuinely sorry." He went on to state that the company plans to "begin a strategic review and analysis of our decision-making process for financial contributions in the public policy arena."

While addressing the question of Emmer's homophobia, Steinhafel's letter also expressed Target's intention to continue funding political campaigns. In this regard, he seems to be moving close to the position endorsed by the Human Rights Campaign (HRC), which wrote that it has "asked [Target] to make it right by contributing to groups that support pro-equality candidates."

Target's Outreach to Gays

The HRC's relationship to Target is particularly interesting.

As America's most prominent lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender advocacy group, it indexes companies based upon the inclusiveness of their workplaces. In its 2010 review, the average score was 86%; Target achieved 100% rating. Among other things, that score indicates Target offers transgender-inclusive insurance coverage, provides full health benefits for domestic partners, "Positively Engages the External LGBT Community," and has a firm-wide diversity council. Target also has a "GLBT Business Council" that works with employees to foster inclusion in the greater community.

It seems likely that Target's score will drop next year: one of the HRC's criteria measures whether or not an employer "Exhibits Responsible Behavior Toward the LGBT Community" and "Does Not Engage in Action That Would Undermine LGBT Equality." While this doesn't directly contribute to a company's score, the HRC notes that "Employers Found Engaging in Such Activities Will Have 15 Points Removed From Their Scores." So it sounds like Target is looking at an 85% in 2011.

Lasting Damage?

Target clearly made a expensive mistake: according to some analysts, its decision to give money to MN Forward has already cost $1.3 billion in market capitalization. Since July 27, the company's share price has dropped by 3.5%. Although Target has asserted that the fall could be attributed to any number of factors, the alienation of hundreds of thousands of consumers would likely be enough to worry any investor. And even if Target manages to repair its relationship with liberal customers, this fiasco should worry any companies that plan to get involved in politics.

For Hogue, that is exactly the point. In an earlier video, she noted that direct action of the sort practiced by MoveOn can "promote something we call a psychic break," which can "radically shift an individual's perspective and...get them to ask questions that they might not otherwise ask." In this case, as millions of customers now wonder if Target is homophobic, and hundreds of companies question the wisdom of political donations, it's clear that MoveOn's tactics have been successful.

Asked if MoveOn intends to launch comparable campaigns against other companies, Hogue responded that "Any company that feels it's acceptable to meddle in our our Democracy and buy elections will face outrage from customers, employees and stockholders." Whether or not that outrage will be fueled by MoveOn remains to be seen.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Introduction to ETFs

The basics of Exchange Traded Funds and why ETFs are hot.

View Course »

Managing your Portfolio

Keeping your portfolio and financial life fit!

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

40 Comments

Filter by:
whatever

i just want to get my toilet paper and get out.

August 14 2010 at 5:44 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
admiral1987

gay or not Target is better then Wally world and will take them down. As middle management in retail I see first hand that upper management has no clue to anything other the numbers and how to make more money. Step on the gays and lesbos they don't care. To bad for haerd working people like me. I could care a less if you were gay, as long aas you worked your ass off getting the job done.

August 13 2010 at 10:11 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
jerrym930

Can someone show me where it is written that MoveOn.Org has all the right answers about life, politics, or any other issue? Most of the things I read and hear about the people in this group show that they act like teenagers who just got grounded by their parents. They act like immature idiots throwing a temper tantrum. We have shopped at Target for years, and will continue to do so. I do not base my shopping habits on anyone's political view, but instead based on the value of the products they sale. It looks to me like MoveOn.Org is inhabited by the "Anti-Everything"idiots of the 1960s. They claim it was the decade of "Enlightenment". The truth is they just became light-headed because of all the drugs they took. I am sure they lost some of their brain cells back then, which now makes it impossible to show them how they are mistaken in their way of thinking.

August 08 2010 at 5:11 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
Willie

I WILL SHOP AT TARGET JUST B/C OF THESE LOONS

August 07 2010 at 6:32 PM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Willie's comment
boca1951

give me a break... leave target alone... this is america freedom of choice.. dont like target dont shop there.. i will shop at target..

August 07 2010 at 3:25 PM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
parthenon1

I am not a big customer of Target. I have been upset about their support of all left wing groups and refusal to support Christian beliefs, they wont allow Salvation Army put kettles in front of their stores or wont allow the utterance by employees of "Merry Christmas" favoring instead "Happy Holidays".

But as for election Right wing or Left wing support with contributions I dont care as long as Labor Unions can support or boycot anything to do with elections I believe those of us who know the leadership of most labor unions are socialist/maiist or communist leaning will fight against them when we can.

August 07 2010 at 2:07 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mandmp11

7.29.2010; The Labor UNION PAC, Americans for a Better Minnesota has already spent $686,000.00 on attack ads against Emmer. So who is trying to buy the election. Target donates $150,000.00 of which a small amount may go to Emmer's campaign and ill informed/ignorant people want a boycott of Target for trying to buy the election. When will you boycott the Unions, but that's OK isn't it.
As for the lady ("B") in the video who cut up her Target credit card, she will be taping it back together after her first visit to a Walmart.
Question Walmart shoppers, is it the product, employees or the customers that make Walmart stores smell funny, or is it a combination of the three? The only times I have ever been in a Wally store was to return defective crap a neighbor who is disabled purchased online, so what's with that smell, could it be a health hazard?
$686,000.00 from unions for ads against Emmer's and some people are OK with that, what a joke you all are.
We shop at Target and always will. M&M

August 07 2010 at 1:47 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Rossen Vassilev

snowwater91: "...I will be putting in an order with my broker for a large amount of Target stock for Monday. Sorry, I cannot finish the rest of my thoughts as I am going to Target to stock up on everything I can fit in my SUV!" Ha-ha! You will buy Target stock? You live in a public park in a hovel without doors, windows or plumbing like a real caveman and eat from garbage cans....

August 07 2010 at 12:02 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Rossen Vassilev's comment
rebeka57

This is a hoax boycott brought to you by democratic liberals. They are just trying to scare off other potential corporate donors from donating to conservative candidates. We are living in a time when a few bratty snot nosed bullies are trying to tell real Americans how to think, act and what to believe in. The media is run by democratic liberals. They are like the wizard of oz. All lies and smoking mirrors. The joke is on them because real Americans may not be vocal but we are lying in wait to take this country back.

August 07 2010 at 11:51 AM Report abuse -4 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to rebeka57's comment
snowwater91

If target supports a candidate that is pro business, anti ILLEGAL immigration and for family values, I have a new respect for them. I will be putting in an order with my broker for a large amount of Target stock for Monday. Sorry, I cannot finish the rest of my thoughts as I am going to Target to stock up on everything I can fit in my SUV!!!!

August 07 2010 at 10:02 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply