What the U.S. Can Learn from Germany's Economic Rebound Many investors are taking a wait-and-see approach on the question of whether Europe's surprisingly sharp economic rebound is sustainable -- and understandably so. With much of the world's economy apparently slowing down, the Continent will be swimming against even stronger tides as it attempts to keep its impressive momentum going.

But as U.S. voters and policymakers head toward this fall's midterm congressional elections, it could be highly instructive to examine the prominent features of European economic juggernauts like Germany that have nearly recouped all the jobs they lost during the downturn.

During the credit-fueled boom just a few years ago, American private-equity firms backed by easy money seemed unstoppable, and commentators predicted that future for the German model of provisioning generous rights for workers was limited.

Of course, the credit bubble fueling much of that private-equity bravado came to a disastrous end. And the remarkable competitiveness of German titans like Volkswagen (VLKAY), Daimler (DDAIF), BMW (BAMXY) and Siemans AG (SI) on the world stage means that the tables might now be turning.

Egalitarian German Model Beats U.S. on Jobs, Exports


The German model has long been hailed as more egalitarian than its American counterpart. At large German companies, for example, half of a supervisory board -- which plays a key role in determining the company's strategy and direction -- is elected by employees. That stands in stark contrast to the dog-eat-dog world of American capitalism, where companies are run only to maximize profits for shareholders.

But along with more egalitarian, it may be more effective as well in relation to some big goals the U.S. is striving top achieve. President Obama is pushing to double U.S. exports over the next five years in attempt to tap into fast-growing emerging markets. Germany, though, is already a bigger exporter than the U.S. despite having an overall GDP that is much smaller: about $3.7 trillion, to America's nearly $15 trillion.

Despite having mounds of cash on hand from cutting costs during the downturn, American companies have yet to start hiring in a meaningful way to bring down unemployment. But Germany has posted 13 consecutive months of job growth.

The German rebound comes at a time when the standoff in the U.S. between business, labor and government is growing increasingly tense. Finger-pointing has been rising as the jobless rate continues to hover above 9% and talk of painful deflationary conditions picks up.

Discussions about how a stakeholder model might work in the U.S., meanwhile, were on the rise following the financial crisis and during the government's widely criticized dealings with Chrysler's creditors. But those discussions seem to have taken a backseat to schemes like more stimulus spending to prop up the American system in the short run as weak job growth continues to frustrate policymakers and Main Street alike.

Germany's robust and broadly shared rebound, though, suggests that its model may hold many insights for those seeking to creating sustainable growth in the U.S.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

How much house can I afford

Home buying 101, evaluating one of your most important financial decisions.

View Course »

Intro to Retirement

Get started early planning for your long term future.

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

86 Comments

Filter by:
nuevepaul

If the right wing commentators address this issue, it would be with the language of "common sense" in which socialism and taxes are demonized as the downfall of our way of life. I have heard is said that in our system the CEO's pay is set by the board of directors' and the pay for the board of directors' is set by the CEO. In our system the CEO makes an income of hundreds or thousands of times more than the average worker. In Japan the CEO makes less than 20 times the pay of the average worker. Makes you wonder how they get by. When the middle class shares the reigns of control of corporations the lot of the average American will improved, and to hell with the status quo.

August 02 2010 at 8:35 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
obama fools

why do you think american company have a lot of cash and are not hiring??? because they dont know what nobams is going to do .........my small busines has a lot of cash .we are not going to spend or hire for 4 more years till washingto is clear out of its rats.............

August 02 2010 at 8:13 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to obama fools's comment
GN

Your are not going to hire because you are making money where you are now. If I had a business making lots of money I wouldn't hire people for no reason I doubt most businesses are making a conscious choice to not hire they don't hire because they don't have more demand to fill, but this is all just assumption and generalization, Does what I say make sense? Or is it idealized and not the reality? I ask earnestly.

May 05 2012 at 11:24 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Terry

What scares me is that while Germany is the world's 4th largest economy at 3.7 Trillion that still is less than our Federal budget for this year under Obama. Not to mention all our other taxes at the State, County, City and Township levels. We really can't have less government???

August 02 2010 at 8:08 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Terry's comment
GN

With my limited knowledge of governmental structure I really don't know what we could possible cut. If I made you emperor of the us what would you cut?

May 05 2012 at 11:25 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Louis Gahafer

The problem here in the US is GREED , PLAIN & SIMPLE. Also our goverment to big & they will not work together . They need to start doing what they were elected to do & that is to take care of the problems here in the US & quit meddling in everyone else,s buisness . There MAIN focus SHOULD BE FOR THE AMERICAN PEOPLE . The GUY,S IN WASHINGTON need to quit fighting each other and TAKE CARE OF OF THIS COUNTRY FIRST !!!!!!! The AMERICAN ( TRUE AMERICANS )PEOPLE SHOULD COME FIRST BEFORE ANYONE ELSE .......

August 02 2010 at 8:01 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Paul FIQUET

With our #1 mentality anyone who thinks we could learn from some other country is dreaming.

August 02 2010 at 8:00 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
garyrjas

This is how intelligent people are on this blog. They say they hate Obama for trying to turn us toward socialism but point to Germany as a success story, and Germany is socialist !!!. Yes, my friend, they pay much higher taxes, but they are taken care of from the womb to the tomb as a result. And employees participating in management? Isn't that similar to the U word (union)? Wow, how scary !!!!!

August 02 2010 at 7:51 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply
garyrjas

Gee, all you Obama haters must hate this story, a socialist approach and its working??? One false point, we in no way are headed toward deflation. Energy costs along are going up, and therefore everything with it will also increase. No Virginia, there is not going to be deflation, and in about 2 years, look for about 5% with all the free money floating around.

August 02 2010 at 7:48 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
bemahuron

Learn from Germany??? I don't think we have to look any further than Washington to identify where our problems originate. Hopefully we'll start taking care of that in November.

August 02 2010 at 7:38 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mac2jr

What if you are all wrong and Mexico sues us for not giving their people work?

People bitch about the illegals taking American Jobs. But, what if you are all wrong and Mexico ....

What if you are all wrong and Mexico can claim that the 'sale' was illegal, that would mean that we would have to give back California, Texas, New Mexico and Arizona. Think about it, we won by war, an illegal war against Mexico and our Native Americans, then offered peanuts to shut them up.

Now what if Mexico sues us for taking all their water, as we did and still do? We have basically killed their livelihood as

farmers and producers by draining the Rio Grande and the Colorado and dozens of other rivers, before each can reach Mexico.

Now what if Mexico sues us for our use of Illegal Dope, which is the cause of much of the problems. We STUPID, and usually fairly well-off Americans use the dope that is causing the crime and the wars.

What if Mexico sues our Corporations for their 'bait and switch' activities of bringing in factories for our profits, having millions of Mexicans move to the borders, and then we pull out and move to China.

What if Mexico decides to 'Deport' all the Americans living there, we would have tens of thousands returning to America, all without a place to live, and therefore on Welfare or other government programs.

What if Mexico decides to 'Stop' its oil flow from coming into the USA, we would lose about 30% of our oil.

What if Mexico decides to 'Stop' its food stuffs from coming into the USA, our produce and meat prices would skyrocket.

What if Mexico decides to 'Stop' tourist from the USA and only caters to the Europeans or worse, the Chinese. We would lose billions as much of the tourist industry is USA owned or backed.

What if Mexico declares 'war' on the USA, as it probably should. We are already in two wars and our troops are on third and fourth tours, we would be overwhelmed trying to guard or fight a 'hand to hand' war along nearly 2,000 miles of southern border.

And while we are at it, what is to stop the 'bad' guys from coming in through Canada, we have a wide open 3,000 mile border there.

The list goes on and on, and you people need to do your homework and learn some history and do some thinking; we are the

'BAD' guys when it comes to Mexican policies, and we need to 'Clean up' our act.

August 02 2010 at 7:36 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
mac2jr

Companies that will make it in the future.

1) Medical education
2) Office paperwork to computer
3) Document scanning
4) Legal advisors for tort and divorce cases
5) Water purification product producers
6) Alternative Energy suppliers
7) Alternative Transportation suppliers
8) Alternative food suppliers
9) Dollar Stores

August 02 2010 at 7:33 AM Report abuse +1 rate up rate down Reply