Skip to Content

G20 nations agree to continue stimulus, split on financial transactions tax

Text SizeAAA

Filed under: Economy, Investing

More

g20-nations-agree-to-continue-stimulus-split-on-financial-transMarkets soared worldwide following the announcement of the decision by the G20 finance leaders to maintain stimulus measures as long as U.S. employment figures remained weak. They agreed the stimulus is needed until the recovery is assured.

But G20 members were split on how to assure that there will never again be a need for a similar bailout. U.K. Prime Minister Gordon Brown (pictured) shocked many attendees when he announced support for a tax on financial transactions. This tax would be used to pay for future bailouts. Germany and France have been pushing the idea, but this is the first time the U.K. had come out in favor of it.

U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner said the U.S. would not support a bank-transaction tax. Canada and Russia also are opposed to a transaction tax, so it's unlikely there will be a global consensus.

If some countries decide to impose the tax while others don't, that could change how money moves around the world. Companies would prefer to handle transactions with countries that don't impose the tax. So unless the G20 comes to some agreement, I doubt we'll see a financial transaction tax any time soon.

But the fact that the U.K. is now on board could help to add to the momentum for a financial transactions tax. Dominique Strauss-Kahn, managing director of the International Monetary Fund, told the G20 ministers that the IMF is also studying the idea of some kind of tax. The IMF wants to determine whether a tax could be an incentive for financial institutions to take fewer risks. The big benefit of such a tax would be to create an insurance fund to be used in case of a future crisis.

A Drastic Change to Bankruptcy Law


Right now, Geithner believes in a different plan for avoiding future bailouts. Congress and the Treasury Department have developed draft legislation that they say will make sure that "the taxpayers are never again called upon to take responsibility for Wall Street's business decisions."

We can only believe those words when we see the final version of the bill that passes Congress. The bill as currently proposed does give the federal government the right to seize control of troubled financial institutions that are deemed "too big to fail," fire their top executives, wipe out shareholders and rewrite the institution's loan agreements, but I suspect that such a broad grant of authority won't last through the legislative process. It's too drastic a change from current bankruptcy law, and you can be certain that bondholders and other interested parties will quickly lobby for it to be toned down. Another key provision to protect taxpayers is the creation of a Resolution Fund to spread the cost of bailing out a large financial institution with assets over $10 billion among a broad range of financial companies, rather than having the taxpayers foot the bill. This fund will be built using assessments on financial companies with assets over $10 billion.

Would the U.S. plan to avoid future bailouts, if passed as now envisioned by Geithner, be workable in other countries? Given the differences in how financial institutions are regulated worldwide, probably not.

Instead, Geithner needs to be concerned about how to develop a global plan to prevent the need for future bailouts. If all other major countries were to finally buy into the idea of a financial transactions tax, would the U.S. be able to maintain a global presence without agreeing to it?

Lita Epstein has written more than 25 books, including Trading for Dummies and The Complete Idiot's Guide to the Federal Reserve.

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments.

When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password.

To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to 3 URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br /> tags.

Interest Rates

5/1 ARM+4.19%APR: +3.81%
30 Yr.
Fixed Mort.
+5.02%APR: +5.16%
$30K
HELOC
+8.00%APR: 0.00%
30 Mo
New Car Loan
+6.79%APR: 0.00%
1 Yr. CD+1.57%APR: +1.58%
DailyFinance Writers
Melly Alazraki Melly Alazraki Financial writer and analyst
James Altucher James Altucher Financial columnist
Jeff Bercovici Jeff Bercovici Media columnist
Jonathan Berr Jonathan Berr Financial writer and media columnist
Mercedes Cardona Mercedes Cardona Retail reporter
Tim Catts Tim Catts Financial writer
Peter Cohan Peter Cohan Author, venture capitalist and financial writer
Carrie Coolidge Carrie Coolidge Financial writer
Lita Epstein Lita Epstein Financial writer
Sam Gustin Sam Gustin Technology Writer
Nikhil Hutheesing Nikhil Hutheesing Tech and investing editor
Joseph Lazzaro Joseph Lazzaro Markets and economics writer
Latif Lewis Michelle Leder Financial Columnist
Latif Lewis Latif Lewis Business news editor and management columnist
Anthony Massucci Anthony Massucci Senior writer and tech columnist
Doug McIntyre Doug McIntyre Business and investing news writer and editor
Michael Mercurio Michael Mercurio Managing Editor
Todd Pruzan Todd Pruzan Features editor
Michael Rainey Michael Rainey Editor and economics writer
Alex Salkever Alex Salkever Senior technology writer
David Schepp David Schepp Business News reporter
Matthew Scott Matthew Scott Investing reporter and editor
Dan Solin Daniel R. Solin Author, investment advisor and retirement expert
Amey Stone Amey Stone Executive editor
Bruce Watson Mark Svenvold Columnist, renewable energy
Russel Turk, M.D. Russell Turk, M.D. Healthcare policy columnist
Bruce Watson Bruce Watson Features Writer
my portfolios

Find out why more people track their portfolios on AOL Money & Finance than anywhere else.

Create a New Portfolio My Portfolios

Daily Finance Partners

More from the Weblogs Network