- Days left

Why the Home Buyer Tax Credit should be allowed to expire

housingIt appears Uncle Sam will keep propping up the still shaky real estate market for months to come. The Senate last night voted to extend the $8,000 first-time home buyers tax credit, and the House followed suit today. The president is expected to soon sign it into law.

But is the bill good for real estate? Not at all. What better way to fix a bubble caused by way too much home ownership than to encourage more home ownership?

Extending the home buyer tax credit is a bad idea because the real estate market doesn't need it. The panic phase of the housing crisis is essentially over. Americans know full well that house prices are no longer in free fall, but still have a ways to go before resembling anything close to a recovery.

Real estate experts have long argued that slumping prices and dwindling sales are a natural and necessary part of the real estate cycle. Extending the tax credit will only help lower and middle class Americans buy homes they can't afford, which will likely exacerbate the housing problem and may even trigger another mini-bubble in some markets.

In fact, a handful of local and state housing agencies are already providing second mortgages to buyers who don't have enough money for down payments so that they might turn the tax credit into cash. Down-payment assistance helped fuel the housing crisis in the first place because it helped people buy homes they couldn't afford.

I've already written in this column about the bidding wars now underway in some places for low and mid-priced homes as the tax deadline loomed. Extending a tax break to first-time buyers will only inflate these already somewhat inflated numbers.

The new bill goes beyond giving a leg up to first-timers who place homes under contract by the end of next April. Americans who have lived in their current house for five years and want to buy a new house will be also be able to get in on the action by being eligible for a $6,500 tax credit.

This isn't needed. In many markets prices have fallen so far that houses are actually affordable again in a way they haven't been in years. That's a reason enough to buy a home even without a government handout.

Let's face it, fear and a healthy dose of pandering is why this home buyer tax credit persists. Months of dire warnings from the National Association of Realtors and other formidable real estate lobby groups have spooked not only skittish lawmakers who don't want to appear tone deaf on housing woes.

It's also startled home buyers (aka voters), who now think the government should come to the rescue every time housing numbers tick downward. (For the record, home sales figures have been on an upward trend in many markets for months.)

The housing crisis was triggered, in part, by bloated sale prices, greedy speculators, and overzealous Americans wanting to "get in on the real estate action." Extending the tax credit or any other economic benefit will only serve to put us right back where we started by helping Americans rush to buy when they should be waiting, saving, and renting.

Finally, it's also important to remember another crucial point; Uncle Sam is broke. America is currently carrying record deficits and the bailout-happy Congress will only worsen the problem.

By December 1, the original end to the tax credit deadline, the government will have spent some $8.6 billion on house-buyer payments. Estimates for the proposed extension start at close to $12 billion. The lesson? Tax perks for house buyers don't come from the government. They ultimately come from taxpayers.

Troy McMullen writes the weekly INside Real Estate column for WalletPop. He's a former real estate reporter for the Wall Street Journal and Financial Times.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

What is Inflation?

Why do prices go up?

View Course »

How much house can I afford

Home buying 101, evaluating one of your most important financial decisions.

View Course »

TurboTax Articles

Cities with the Highest Tax Rates

Much ado is made in the press about federal tax brackets, but cities can carry a tax bite of their own. Even if you live in a state that has no income tax, your city may levy a variety of taxes that could eat away the entire benefit of living in an income tax-free state, including property taxes, sales taxes and auto taxes. Consider all the costs before you move to one of these cities, and understand that rates may change based on your family's income level.

Great Ways to Get Charitable Tax Deductions

Generally, when you give money to a charity, you can use the amount of that donation as a deduction on your tax return. However, not all charities qualify as tax-deductible organizations. While there are many types of charities, they must all meet certain criteria to be classified by the IRS as tax-deductible organizations. There are legitimate tax-deductible organizations in many popular categories, such as those listed below.

A Freelancer's Guide to Taxes

Freelancing certainly has its benefits, but it can result in a few complications come tax time. The Internal Revenue Service considers freelancers to be self-employed, so if you earn income as a freelancer you must file your taxes as a business owner. While you can take additional deductions if you are self-employed, you'll also face additional taxes in the form of the self-employment tax. Here are things to consider as a freelancer when filing your taxes.

Tax Deductions for Voluntary Interest Payments on Student Loans

Most taxpayers who pay interest on student loans can take a tax deduction for the expense ? and you can do this regardless of whether you itemize tax deductions on your return. The rules for claiming the deduction are the same whether the interest payments were required or voluntary.

Tax Tips for Uber, Lyft, Sidecar and other Car Sharing Drivers

When you're a driver for a ride-sharing company such as Uber, Lyft, Sidecar, or other car sharing service, the most important thing to understand about your taxes is that you are probably not an employee of Uber, Lyft or Sidecar. Drivers for these companies are usually independent contractors, a fact that has tax implications, both at filing time and year-round.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum