Bernie Madoff 'astonished' Feds flunked 'accounting 101' and missed his fraud
Filed under: People
It wasn't enough for felonious Ponzi patriarch Bernard Madoff to bilk his clients of over $60 billion in assets. Now, the jailbird stock swindler is trash-talking about the very federal authorities who should have caught him and stopped the largest financial scam in history. In a jailhouse interview released late Friday by H. David Kotz, the Securities & Exchange Commission's inspector-general, Madoff disses SEC investigators as bumbling bureaucrats and says he was "astonished" that no one caught him earlier."It would have been easy for them to see," Madoff said of the clueless financial cops who failed to perform what he called "accounting 101." The interview was among more than 6,000 pages of assorted documents Kotz released on Friday that he has collected during his investigation of years worth of the SEC's Madoff-related actions.
The young government investigators failed to check such basic information as Madoff's account with Wall Street's central stock-clearing office, not to mention his dealings with the companies that supposedly handled his fictitious trades, the Ponzi master said.
"If you're looking at a Ponzi scheme, it's the first thing you do," Madoff said during the the June 17 jailhouse interview. "It never entered the SEC's mind that it was a Ponzi scheme."
If it had, Madoff asserted, the SEC could have easily uncovered what turned out to be the largest such financial fraud in history and a black eye for the regulatory commission charged with monitoring and stopping exactly such crimes. Instead, SEC examiners relied on Madoff's word -- which turned out to be worth mud -- and other materials he provided, which also were fabricated.
Madoff Lived with a 'Nightmare'
Despite the commission's ineptitude, Madoff said he "was 'worried every time' he was examined or investigated by the SEC, and that 'it was a nightmare for me' because 'it was very basic stuff.' That was the nightmare I lived with." Madoff's fraud cost many people their life savings, pensions and even homes. He was arrested in December, pleaded guilty in March and is now serving a 150-year prison term in North Carolina.
In the interview, Madoff dissed one of the SEC sgents as an "obnoxious guy" who came across like "Lieutenant Colombo" -- Peter Falk's famous, if flaky, TV investigator -- and spent 90 percent of his time checking Madoff's e-mails.
Madoff also described current SEC Chairwoman Mary Schapiro as "a 'dear friend' and that she 'probably thinks I wish I never knew this guy.'" However, this appears to be a yet another Madoff make-believe: Inspector General Kotz, in a statement on Friday about the documents he released, said he found no evidence that Madoff had a close friendship with Schapiro.
Demonstrating that his elevated sense of his own status on Wall Street has remained intact, Madoff suggested that regulators went easy on him thanks to his prestigious posts at various Wall Street institutions, including serving as chairman of the Nasdaq exchange.
SEC Employees Unload
"I'm very proud of the role I played in the industry," Madoff told Kotz. "Of course, I destroyed that now," the Ponzi prince, said, in the understatement of the year.
The interview summary was among 536 exhibits of interviews, letters, e-mail messages and phone records -- released yesterday. These documents formed the basis of Kotz's September report that first placed blame on the SEC for failing to uncover the massive fraud.
Other exhibits released include transcripts of testimony by SEC staffers, in which they absolutely unload on their own employer and rip colleagues as incompetent. SEC investigator Kotz was highly suspicious of the relationship between former SEC attorney Eric Swanson, whose group had oversight of Madoff's trading, and Madoff's niece, Shana, the documents show. They're now married.
Next to Plead Guilty: The Accountant
According to court-appointed trustee Irving Picard, Madoff's crime cost thousands of victims, including individuals, investment funds and charities at least $21 billion in cash, as part of the $65 billion in paper wealth that he's accused of ripping off.
David Friehling, Madoff's accountant from 1991 to 2008, is expected to plead guilty on Tuesday as part of a deal with the government, federal prosecutors said Friday.
Picard has already filed a $199 million lawsuit against the disgraced financier's sons Andrew and Mark, his brother Peter and his niece Shana, alleging that they benefited from Madoff's epic fraud by using his investment firm as a "family piggy bank" to fund their lavish lifestyles. Bernard Madoff's current lifestyle is stark proof of how dramatically their living conditions could change.



























Reader Comments (Page 1 of 16)
10-31-2009 @ 11:51AM
Ed said...
He tricked alot of people, but in the end he ended up right where he belongs, in a jail cell for the rest of his life, now the SEC has to find a way to help those people that he stole from and swindled. There are other people that should believe in one thing, if it sounds to good to be true, guess what, it is.
Reply
10-31-2009 @ 3:04PM
todd said...
You must be kidding me!!! The punishment doesn't fit the crime. He destroyed thousands of peoples lives. He lived a lavish life, vacations all over the world, a yacht, mansion in palm beach, one in the hamptons, etc,etc. He will be dead in less than 2 years, watch and see. Meanwhile the rest off us break our ass's everyday of our lives to make ends meet. Hell, I did harder time then he is seeing when I served 4 years of my life in the military. He gets basically 2 maybe 3 years behind bars at a plush correctional facility , being catered to again on the taxpayers shoulders. Really makes you think of being a career criminal rather then live an honest life. He should be made to suffer, his family and the upper tier of his company knew what was going on and did nothing, they all should be tortured till their last breath of air expells from their lungs!!!!!!!
10-31-2009 @ 6:15PM
jerry mcdonald said...
He may be,but the congress,president,geithner,bernake,summers,clinto,greenspan,paulson,ceo's are not.The constitution calls for death,manipulation of the currency,may the sentance be carried out.
10-31-2009 @ 11:59AM
Sonja said...
This is just indicative of how the government hires young green horn accountants for the SEC that are supposed to be watching over the finances of this country. What a joke!! Gee, I wonder how many of them are grads. of the Ivy League schools?? I'd love to see a list of names and universities where they graduated from!?
Reply
10-31-2009 @ 4:10PM
Sophie said...
You're perfectly right, Sonja: in the U.S., you can become an accountant and graduate from the so-called "best schools" with a LOW IQ (110 and under). All it takes is a little bit of work and a good memory. However, once they get hired - above others, needless to say - they are incompetent because after all, it's math and intelligence is required to do a better than average job! I get paid to fix financial gaffes created by accountants! LOL I have a B.A. in Math and Physics but learned finance ON MY OWN! (But am a Mensa member with 152 IQ on the Stanford Binet II...) WHEN ARE EMPLOYERS GOING TO REALIZE THAT A NICE DIPLOMA MEANS S**T, IT'S THE IQ THAT MATTERS! I guess after they get screwed over and over... ^_^ My clients got the message. Last week, yet another one hired me after his accountant failed to notice that an employee was using his credit card for his own car rentals instead of the company's. I found it out in 10 minutes and a phonecall when I offered said client to look at his company's finances for free to see if I could improve his business. Sad...
11-01-2009 @ 7:10AM
Bill P said...
How about all the non-government Wall Street smarties who also missed it? Don't be so condemning until you have walked in the Feds shoes a while. Madoff had a lot of high powered backers and reputation that would make it quite difficult for a Federal inspector to try to bring him down. Not saying that they shouldn't have caught him, just saying it isn't an indication that the government always screws things up. There were plenty of people on Wall Street who lost money because they didn't do their due diligence. Bill
11-01-2009 @ 12:32PM
Amy said...
what the hell happened to Chris Cox the head of SEc at the time this was going on?
11-01-2009 @ 2:52AM
koolwoman said...
Let's not forget that Madoff thievery happened under GW Bush and his hand picked cronies. The head of SEC was a young Republican congressman,with no experience in this field, kinda like Brownie, Bush's selection for Homeland Security, who let New Orleans drown.
11-01-2009 @ 7:03AM
ArtBCPA said...
Sonja, Amy, and Koolwoman: You need to get your facts straight. Every business hires recent graduates; then they are trained and supervised by experienced supervisors. The problems with the SEC have nothing to do with the universities they graduated from. In fact, nearly all of Enron's people came from Ivy League schools. With regard to Chris Cox and GWB, the Madoff scandal was going on for 30+ years. Not that they did any better than their predecessors, but this can't be laid at the feet of the people in office at the time it was discovered.
If you want to know more about the Madoff scandal, you can go to my website: http://accountingethics.blogspot.com/.
11-01-2009 @ 1:47PM
George said...
Sonja it is easy to blame the young employees, but did wall street not owe a duty to the public as a major buisness to observe that Madoff was not trading yet publicly doing buisness as a wall street trader and collecting cash for the buisness.
What happens to wall streets responsibility to protect itself and the public from misrepresentation. One must bear in mind that this was a very collective and institutional crime. Madoff is just a good soldier.
This is a studdied fraud, part of a larger plan the destroy the United States as a super power. What they did not expect is that the leadership would suspend the capitalist arthodoxy and borrow that much money to maintain the system. They did not expect us to tout too big to fail. Now they are talking deficit like its a problem not withstanding the circumstances.
11-02-2009 @ 1:04AM
Al yer pal said...
I fully agree! Today, a degree means nothing more that a person knows how to go off and spend four years partying with their buddies.
11-02-2009 @ 1:17AM
Al yer pal said...
I fuly agree! Today, a degree means nothing more than having proof that you can spend four years drinking with your buddies. When I hire someone, I often consider their degree as a lower criteria element to landing the job than their common sense and attitude toward life and people in general. Honestly, they can wear a tux or formal to the interview, show up promptly and have all the pre-fab answers. They KNOW that those basic things in the forefront and will see to those items; however, among other things, I often try to catch at least a glimpse of their car. Filthy windows on their car is a definite ding on their brain. I mean, if they don't care to have clear vision when doing something as simple as driving, how can I expect them to have clear vision when handling a complex part of my company?
10-31-2009 @ 12:11PM
chip griswold said...
Typical narcississtic dope. Now it is the SEC's fault for not catching him sooner! Can't get much more pathetic than that. You robbed these people, not the SEC. Hope you rot in prison. His arrogance shows how little he cares for others.
Reply
10-31-2009 @ 1:10PM
bob steinhardt said...
Chip Your comments are right on the money. This man is one sick person and he doesnt know right from wrong. He ruined many institutions also. I would hope that the government goes after his family in a big way. His sons worked for him for many years. Unless they are completel morons they had to be involved. This family has no shame.
Bob Steinhardt
10-31-2009 @ 5:29PM
Val said...
Yup! You're absolutely right. So now the real culprit is the SEC because they didn't catch his fraud - NOT!. Well slap their hands too. Some heads should roll on that one but Madoff did this to his investors and himself. He really didn't think that much about his grandkids and how far down the Madoff line this is going to affect did he?
11-01-2009 @ 9:39AM
Laurie said...
You are right, apparently delusions of grandeur run deep and are lasting; he's even more sick and disgusting evidenced by the fact that he has seemingly not been humbled at all by spending his life behind bars. He clearly has no conscience, no sense of reality ie: right vs. wrong, he's almost inhuman, how do you take ANYTHING from someone else that doesn't belong to you and...take money from charities?? He's beyond sick and beyond redemption.. He deserves to rot in hell..My heart goes out to his victims.
10-31-2009 @ 12:11PM
woody said...
top members of the SEC and all of Madoff's family, including wife and sons should either be in jail or sued to the extent that they can only afford to rent in a trailer park
Reply
10-31-2009 @ 8:50PM
Mac said...
Whats wrong with trailers? I live in one!
11-01-2009 @ 8:28PM
buncle said...
Who says a trailer park would want them there?
Reply
10-31-2009 @ 12:20PM
trmnatr2 said...
you cant say he's wrong here.the sec isnt going to help these people who lost their money,no one will.they may get a small percenrtage of what they lost but thats all. thats what happens when you get greedy.
Reply