Schwarzenegger to television makers: Go green or stay out of California
Filed under: Energy, Technology
First it was the makers of gas-guzzling autos. Next, the Governator came down hard on coal-fired power plants. Now, California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger has multinational electronics makers in his executive crosshairs. His mission? To rid the Golden State of big, energy-hogging televisions that suck up so much juice in brown-out prone California. As the Golden State goes, so might go the nation. With what is effectively the eighth-largest economy in the world, California policies can force compliance in consumer electronics manufacturing and drive a green energy agenda like no other state of the union.
Written by the California Energy Commission (CEC), the proposed California regulation could pass as early as Nov. 4, according to The Los Angeles Times. It would put in place a set of energy efficiency mandates for large-screen TVs that would effectively ban the current generation of plasma TVs with screens over 40 inches. The law would require a 33 percent improvement in energy efficiency for all TVs sold starting Jan. 1, 2011, and a whopping 50 percent improvement for sets sold starting Jan. 1, 2013.
The numbers behind the proposal are eye-opening. According the Commission's website, "In California, televisions (along with DVRs, DVD players, and cable/satellite boxes) now consume about 10 percent of a home's electricity. Increasing sales of flat screen televisions, larger screen sizes, the growing number of TVs per household, and increased daily use of televisions all contribute to greater electricity consumption." There are at present 35 million TVs in California, by most estimates.
Surprisingly, a law that could literally tell red-blooded sports fans what type of TV they can buy has caused little public uproar. Perhaps Californians, battered by a 12 percent unemployment rate and massive state budget cuts, aren't feeling like buying a big screen these days?
However, the Consumer Electronics Association, the industry trade group representing manufacturers, has been staunchly against the mandates, arguing that it pushes too hard and too fast for energy improvements that will dramatically jack up the cost of sets and hurt electronics sales, not to mention already-ailing electronics retailers and component manufacturers. In a hearing of the CEC on Oct. 13, CEA representative Douglas Johnson said, "The core concern here really has to do with the element of the Commission's proposed regulations that would impose a mandatory power consumption limit on televisions. Such regulation undercuts innovation, it does harm consumers, ultimately, and it certainly harms TV manufacturers in related industries."
Johnson also stated he believes that the current voluntary national Energy Star programs that encourage appliance efficiency by awarding Energy Star status to specific units was working just fine and that the CEC was relying on outdated data in making its assumptions about how much energy the state would really save by enforcing such a mandate. To some degree, Johnson is correct. Television manufacturers are actively embracing efficiency measures such as using low-energy light emitting diodes to replace other types of lighting modules in sets and building in dimming technologies that automatically dim portions of a screen not required to show light. All of these technologies do cost more than older technologies which have already achieved economics of scale.
Whether the manufacturers can make the mandate or not without extreme pain is a matter open for clear discussion. At the same October hearing, Kenneth Lowe, the Chief Technical Officer of flat-panel TV maker Vizio, said: "Today, several of our models already meet the proposed Tier 2 levels, and that are not scheduled to go into effect until Jan. 1, 2013. We are in the process of redesigning our other models so that the new designs will meet these levels by the CEC deadlines." Lowe and other estimated that the end cost to consumers would be roughly an additional $40 per set. Lowe should know: Vizio is the largest maker of flat-panel TVs and monitors in the U.S. and sells both budget and high-end lines.
If the disputed CEC numbers on energy consumption from TVs are correct, the wide-ranging impacts of this rule change could be profound. A 50 percent improvement of energy efficiency applied to a product set that consumes 10 percent of total energy implies, over time, a maximum five percent energy savings. That's an enormous savings, one that could reduce the need for hundreds of new power plants around the country.
If forced to change their designs to comply with California regulations, set manufacturers will likely sell those same TVs elsewhere in the country and quickly upgrade their product lines to match the California rules. They almost have no choice, considering the size of the California market and the costs incurred by running one set of products for California and another for the rest of the country. And other states are likely to follow California's regulatory lead. The Governator may drive a Hummer, but it's a hybrid, and his eco-cred will only be burnished by this gambit to put the big boob tube on an energy diet.
Alex Salkever is Senior Writer at AOL Daily Finance covering technology and greentech. Follow him on twitter @alexsalkever, read his articles, or email him at alex@dailyfinance.com.



























Reader Comments (Page 1 of 26)
10-26-2009 @ 3:57PM
Ken said...
Why not restrict birth rates? That is root cause!
Reply
10-26-2009 @ 4:51PM
Alfred Schrader said...
Wide screen Tv's ARE energy efficient. They use Liquid Crystals or LEDs (Light Emmiting Diodes).
He must mean a ban on the older big CRT screen Tv's that use half a kilowatt.
I love Ahnold, but isn't that Hummer thing like a guzzler ?
Is that green ?
Al
10-26-2009 @ 5:23PM
Richard said...
Are you volunteering for retroactive birth control?
10-26-2009 @ 6:50PM
Tom Nichols said...
Why not ask Arnold to commit suicide...he's done that politically already
10-26-2009 @ 7:59PM
justlegalizeit09 said...
sure, plasmas and LCD's use up a lot of power... but LED tv's use a fraction of that..... just let technology take its course... soon LED tv's will be the standard and flexible plasic screens will be the new things..... technology moves fast.... unlike automotive technology which is meant to make sure hundreds of thousands of new cars are bought every year..
11-10-2009 @ 8:16PM
John said...
THE TERMINATOR LIVES,,,,,,,,Arnold has done more for California and rebounds across the nation than any other governor in the USA.......Go get Arnold! !
10-27-2009 @ 11:01AM
al said...
I agree with ya Ken. Population is getting out of hand
10-27-2009 @ 6:24PM
JOHNNY ROTTEN said...
THEY ALREADY HAVE RESTRICTED BIRTH RATES FOR WHITES,OUR WOMEN WORK AND DONT HAVE CHILDREN OUR MONEY IS GIVEN TO MINORITIES FOR FREE PUBLIC HOUSING,FOOD STAMPS FREE MEDICAL CARE AD INFINITUM THE UNDER AGE 18 POPULATION OF THIS COUNTRY IS OVER 72% NON WHITE.DO YOU THINK THEY ARE GOING TO TAKE CARE OF US?
10-27-2009 @ 6:45PM
Mark said...
You liberals always want to limit population growth but none of you ever volunteer to end YOUR lives.
10-27-2009 @ 6:46PM
pnut166 said...
How `bout those illegal aliens? How much power do they use? How `bout this, Arnie: price electricity accordingly, and if someone can afford to run a big-ass TV, let`em. I can live in "Caleeforneya" and sit around and smoke pot, but not own a TV big enough to see through all the smoke and watery eyes? What a ripoff ! Hey, I got it! Put all the illegal aliens on a shltload of hamster wheels and make `em power the grid ! PNUT FOR GOVENOR 2012 !!!!!!!!!!!!
10-27-2009 @ 10:33PM
cat outten said...
What everybody seems to forget when they UBER regulate EVERYTHING is that they are forcing PRODUCERS to quit producing, thus cutting back demand and then supply. This leads to companies going out of business. . . and hardworking people lose their jobs. Waging war on our cokes and our flat screen tv's doesn't make us better, healthier people; It makes us people without jobs!
10-28-2009 @ 8:13AM
hookmrl said...
see what happens when no experiecend idiots take charge arnold and nobama it is screw up decisions
10-26-2009 @ 4:01PM
jamie said...
who cares, go out for a roadtrip and buy one. One more thing for them to bring across the border before they find a place to call home.
Reply
10-26-2009 @ 4:01PM
phil said...
FU Arnold! Lease my Big Screen Alone !!!
Reply
10-27-2009 @ 3:27PM
Ken Layton said...
Big screen tv's at home are not the problem.
What is the problem is the megaplex movie theaters with those "digital cinema" video projectors using 5000 to 10,000 watt xenon bulbs. Same with the new video IMAX theaters. Those are the real energy hogs. We need to close those theaters or have them install smaller screens so they can use 1000 or 2000 watt bulbs instead.
Oh yes, those popcorn poppers in the snack bar use 5000 watts or more to make those huge batches of popcorn. We need to go back to the days of single screen mom and pop theaters with smaller screens.
10-27-2009 @ 5:15PM
Luckysunday22 said...
Hey Ken, you know what the real problem is? People like you and other liberals who keep putting their nose in other peoples business. If they can afford to opperate at that energy consumption rate, then they should be able to buy or use anything they god damn please. If you don't want to own one, that's your personal choice. Stop making other peoples personal choices for them, you don't have the right!
10-26-2009 @ 4:11PM
denistenn said...
go get them, gov. if you do a 1000 thing right, they will remenber the things that they think where wrong..................if you could only do something about the speaker of the house, in d.c what,s her face..........................now ther would be something to talk about.........
Reply
10-27-2009 @ 8:12PM
mark said...
Are you referring to that rare creature commonly known as the bug-eyed left-winged nitwit? (Getting rid of Pelosi would be the best thing to happen to the Democratic Party in a long time.)
(I'm a formerly Republican-leaning independent who stopped voting repugnican in 2000, thinks Arnold is the best thing to ever happen to California, and now tend to vote Democrat; as David Gergen said: "the Right moved so far right they left me left...)
10-27-2009 @ 11:39PM
Roger said...
LOL ... That's pretty funny! Arnold is an idiot and proven he can't handle running this state. First thing he did was cut vehicle registration fees ... then the next year he added it back in ... then increased it ... funny how republicans say they want LESS government and then they applaud STUPID misguided BS spin politics and REGULATE the TV manufacturers which results in more job losses. His budget this year is very misguided in to what got cut ... people putting their kids thru college are paying more for less ... furlough days every week cutting pay from 10-15% and big Arnold ... driving his gas hog Hummer smoking his Cuban cigars is as lousy politician ... probably worse ... than he was as an actor. He has done nothing to improve this state that wouldn't have happened with Gray Davis still serving as Governor. The steroids have turned his brain to mush. Lousy actor ... Lousy Governor!
10-26-2009 @ 4:11PM
Dwayne said...
People, you let the cat out of the bag by giving the liberals the "mandate" for change. Believe me, it is coming. You will be told how much you can eat, what you can eat, when you can take a trip, what you can watch, what you can do in your own home, when you are to sleep, if you have sex, you'd better not end up with kids, you can only take a bath once a week because you're using too much water, there will be a hot water usage meter, on and on. Don't believe me? here in MN they are trying to get a GPS tracking unit on the cars because we're not driving enough to generate gas tax, so they want to charge you per mile. But they could do that by doing a speedometer read when you license the car. But no, they want to see where you are every day of the week. You guys asked for change. I hope you enjoy it because it's making life hell for those of us you belive the government needs to keep its doggone nose out of my business and do what it was meant to do. Protect me from the enemies outside of the borders. We should be calling on being protected from those maniacs in government who are power hungry and think they need to protect us from ourselves.
Reply