The Galleon case could rock boardrooms from Silicon Valley to Wall Street
Filed under: JP Morgan Chase, Dell, Google , Apple, Bank of America, Cisco Corp
Galleon Holdings, the $3.7 billion hedge fund whose founder, Raj Rajaratnam, is out on $100 million bail for his role at the center of a $20 million insider trading scandal, owns big positions in dozens of public companies. And those companies' share prices and management teams could be in trouble. Of course, Galleon's stakes in these companies are a problem only if any of their employees have followed the same process of tipping Galleon as the public companies I posted about here allegedly did.
Based on Galleon's latest SEC filing on its holdings, as of this August, its 10 biggest common stock positions are as follows:
-
eBay (EBAY):$81 million
-
Apple (AAPL): $59 million
-
Google (GOOG): $59 million
-
OSI Pharmaceuticals (OSIP): $47 million
-
Bank of America (BAC): $33 million
-
JPMorgan Chase (JPM):$31 million
-
Cisco Systems (CSCO): $30 million
-
Dell (DELL): $29 million
-
Nvidia (NVDA): $22 million
-
EMC (EMC): $22 million
Of course, this list is almost two months old, so Galleon may have changed its positions since. But my analysis of expert networks -- about which I posted here -- reveals that they include individuals with the potential to gain access to significant details pertaining to quarterly earnings of some of these companies. Here are two:
-
eBay -- one expert network has 60 members who focus on the company. The list includes James Lippert who claims to sell more than $50,000 in equipment each month on eBay. Two such networks have as a member Brad Schepp, who authored a book on eBay power selling, according to his LinkedIn profile. Is there anything illegal about them sharing sales figures with hedge funds? I lack the legal training to judge.
-
Apple -- this August 2009 article by Zero Hedge suggests that Brightstar, which distributes Apple iPhones, is or was a member of one such network. If a big iPhone distributor shares sales data with hedge funds, is this considered inside information? How would Apple feel if it knew that Brightstar was sharing such information? I don't know.
If Galleon's method for earning profit involved getting insider information from each of these companies, then there could be some serious investigations underway there. And who knows how far up and down the line these investigations could reach?
One thing seems sure -- with most hedge funds escaping any serious SEC investigations so far, the average investor doesn't really have a prayer of making money in stocks when competing against tactics like those Galleon is accused of.
Let's hope that Friday's arrests put fear into the hearts of others who may have used such tactics in the past.
Peter Cohan is a management consultant, Babson professor and author of nine books, including Capital Rising (due in June 2010). Follow him on Twitter. He has no financial interest in the securities mentioned.



























Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
10-18-2009 @ 11:31PM
sgentilejr said...
This story of insider trading by the "Insiders or Pros" demonstrates that they do not actually know anymore than the Little Fish traders and the Big Fish will resort to cheating to ensure trading profits. It looks like their plan was " Win at all cost" and now they will get to find out if the 'cost' is worth it.
Reply
10-19-2009 @ 12:54AM
john brewer said...
one more big fat crook that got caught
Reply
10-19-2009 @ 6:58AM
bg said...
People like this and Madoff need to be taken out old school. When the pain of violating public trust is greater than the wealth which they purse only will this stop. Eliminate the problem.
bg
Reply
10-19-2009 @ 2:44PM
brad schepp said...
You bring up consulting firms and my name, suggesting that consultants may pass on insider information. Since you didn't take the simple additional step of emailing me for further background, I'll provide it here.
I can only speak for myself, but typically I'm asked to bring analysts new to the e-commerce industry up to speed on companies they're starting to cover. I provide the broad strokes about where a business stands relative to its competitors, its current business model, and general execution of its business plan. I'm not privy to specific sales data; I have no secret pipelines into companies such as eBay; and sellers don't share revenue data with me. Even if I did have access to this information I wouldn't pass it on.
All the consulting firms I work with require consultants to sign agreements stating, among other things, that they will not reveal sensitive financial information that has not yet been made public. I take that pledge very seriously.
In the future, before maligning someone's reputation for the sake of an interesting slant for an article, please do a bit more research. Your readers will be better off for it.
Reply
10-20-2009 @ 8:04AM
Ebay Noway said...
Yes Brad Schepp - I agree with you entirely.....
a) Your only speaking for yourself - which amounts to puttling little black marks on a white screen;
b) And just because you make this claim for yourself -
i) Doesn't make it true; and
ii) Your opinion of yourself - has absolutely no bearing on anyone else.
Cough "Enron" Cough - Arrrccchhhhh Cheney, Haliburton and Bush... Cough....
Reply