Hit the mute! Why TV commercials are so loud, and how that may change

Annoyingly loud TV commercials are like the weather. Everyone complains about them, but no one does anything about them. Except that lately, someone is doing something about it. Several someones, in fact. After decades of neglect, the issue is finally getting so much attention that the familiar explosion of noise signaling the start of a commercial pod could soon be a thing of the past.

The fight against excessive commercial volume has two fronts, legislative and technological. The first line of defense on the legal side is the Federal Communications Commission, which mandates that commercials can be no louder than the loudest parts of the programming they accompany.
But this approach has serious limitations. An action show that climaxes in a burst of gunfire is one thing; a commercial that's as loud as a gun going off from start to finish is another -- especially if the lead-in to the commercial is relatively quiet. And in addition to making their commercials as loud as the FCC lets them, marketers also use various technological tricks to make them sound even louder than they are, like packing more sound energy into midrange frequencies, the ones that the human ear is most sensitive to.

To close this loophole, Rep. Anna Eshoo (D-Calif.) introduced a bill in the House of Representatives last year, the Commercial Advertising Loudness Mitigation Act. CALM would charge the FCC to enact regulations prohibiting commercials from being "excessively noisy or strident." The House Energy and Commerce Committee will hold a hearing to consider amendments on the bill Thursday.

And a parallel effort within the TV and consumer-electronics industries may also bear fruit soon. The Advanced Television Systems Committee, a nonprofit whose membership includes broadcast networks, cable operators, and electronics manufacturers, has been working to develop voluntary standards that will let broadcasters measure and effectively modulate the volume of commercials.

"We've been working for over two years to help broadcasters, cable operators, and others come up with a uniform strategy so we can minimize the subjective perception of the volume changing during commercials," Mark Richer, the group's president, tells DailyFinance. "Our experts have developed what we call a recommended practice, which provides guidance to broadcasters and others on how to use our standard in a way that will minimize the 'audio loudness differential,' let's call it, that is bothersome to many people. It's a little more complicated than you would think, and getting everybody to agree on how to do it was not easy."

This week, ATSC will send a ballot to about 190 members seeking approval of the recommendations. Richer expects it to pass within 30 days.

But consumers who don't wish to bet their delicate eardrums on legislation or self-regulation already have some options, and soon they'll have more. TV sets featuring Dolby Volume, a technology that automatically flattens out the sound spikes of commercials, have been on the market for two years. They'll soon be joined by a device called SRS TruVolume, a gadget that performs much the same function while claiming to offer some advantages over Dolby Volume -- above all, distinguishing between commercials and programming, and suppressing the sound levels of the former without affecting the latter.

Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

Finding Stock Ideas

Learn to do your research and find investments.

View Course »

How much house can I afford

Home buying 101, evaluating one of your most important financial decisions.

View Course »

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

3 Comments

Filter by:
Beauty

I hate the way commercials do that. It drives me crazy! Have you ever noticed that it is worst when you are on the phone? Whenever I get on the phone, when there is a commercial it seems to get louder. It's like I can't hear myself think sometimes. I guess this is why I'm getting the new Hopper from DISH. It has this really awesome TruVolume feature. It pretty much levels out all the commercials to sound the same and low. DISH is always finding ways to please their customers. That is why I'm glad I’m a customer and employee with DISH, so I could learn about things like this and get them like everyone else. So if you are as tired as I am on commercials screaming in your ears get the hopper!

January 12 2012 at 11:45 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
commercial hater

totally ineffective strategy on the part of commercials: I am repelled by most commercials and grow to distrust and eventually boycott the companies. especially drug companies. I don't know how they sell their products...with their laundry list of horrific side effects that sound worse than the disease itself. no thanks! I would never take those meds. and muting a commercial when one comes on is a full time job...makes me not want to watch tv at all.

December 18 2011 at 12:21 PM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
lovingthedesert

I think it is poor marketing on their part because I hit the mute when the commercials are loud, and so as a consumer, I am no longer listening to their commercial. If it stayed normal volume, then I would leave it on and possibly even listen to it.

December 16 2011 at 9:21 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply