No Social Security cost of living adjustment for you!

pickpocketFor 50 million Americans currently collecting Social Security, the news that they will receive no yearly cost-of-living adjustment this year for the first time since the COLA was added to the program in 1975 is distressing. However, is it unfair?

The COLA is based on the Bureau of Labor Statistics' Consumer Price index, a monthly and yearly computation that more or less reflects the change in prices of 200 products. The products fall within eight categories; Food and Beverages, Housing, Apparel, Transportation, Medical Care, Recreation, Education and Communication, Other goods and services. It does not include income and Social Security tax, or changes in value of investment items and real estate.

At the end of 2008, SS recipients were given a 5.8% COLA, although the CPI was only up 3.8% for the year. While this might seem like a bonus, remember that 2008 was an atypical year, with energy costs driving the index up to a high of 219.086 before falling back to 215.303 at the end of the year.



Last year's large COLA, the year's low inflation, and the $250 stimulus bonus paid to SS recipients is cited by some as good reasons to bypass an increase for 2009. Among those who speak in favor of some modest increase is the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare, which promotes a 1% increase or one-time $150 payment. This would cost the government around $8 billion.

Supporters of the increase defend their proposal by pointing out that for the elderly, medical costs comprise a disproportionate part of their overall expenses. The BLS medical care index shows these costs are up 2% this year through the end of July. The overall cost of living, on the other hand, is just about where it was at the end of 2009.

The 32 million retirees using Medicare's drug program are looking at an average out of pocket increase for this coverage of $28 per month this year and $30. Unlike Medicare Part B, which cannot by law go up unless the COLA goes up, drug coverage is allowed to rise with the market.

The average Social Security benefit is $1,153 per month. A 1% raise would bump this up by $11.53 a month. If all other expenses remain constant, the increased drug program cost for 2009 represents a 2.5% decline in real income to those using the program.

In this recession, everyone has suffered, and we can only hope that the suffering has been spread out fairly. Social Security recipients are being asked to suffer a little more while we careen recklessly toward the train wreck that is already in sight, the depletion of the fund. It's much easier to swallow a sacrifice today if it is part of a coherent strategy to fix upcoming problems. Unfortunately, I don't think many retirees see any sign Washington intends to do anything about it except nickel and dime them.

Is the 0% COLA fair? I can't decide. The sad fact is that I've become so numbed by trillion dollar deficits and $700 billion stimulus expenses that a mere $8 billion dollars seems like chump change, and our nation's retirees deserve better than that.


Increase your money and finance knowledge from home

How Financial Planners go Grocery Shopping

Learn to shop smart and save.

View Course »

How much house can I afford

Home buying 101, evaluating one of your most important financial decisions.

View Course »

TurboTax Articles

E-file: Income Tax Return Electronic Filing

Forget that paper tax return! Electronic filing (e-filing), online tax preparation and online payment of taxes are getting more popular every year. If you've wondered about e-filing, here are the answers to frequently asked questions, including why e-filing is a good idea, which states let you e-file, how much e-filing costs, and how soon you'll receive your refund.

Multiple States - Where To File

Learn where to file state income taxes, even if you're in the military, or earned money in multiple states. TurboTax will calculate how much you owe to the different states where you have earned income.

Will Medicare/Medicaid be Impacted by ACA?

The Affordable Care Act put in place significant tax-related programs that impact Medicare and Medicaid, such as increased Medicare taxes on earned and unearned income, and Medicaid changes designed to increase the number of insured individuals. Establishing whether you are affected by the ACA-imposed taxes, or are eligible for certain health programs that fall under the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, is determined by filing your income tax.

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum