Rick Wagoner's golden retirement
Filed under: Company News, People
As General Motors (GM) former CEO Rick Wagoner says his farewells at the company where he has worked for over thirty years, he is not receiving the sort of "golden parachute" severance package that has recently fueled populist rage. However, his pension, valued at roughly $23 million, has already raised more than a few eyebrows.
Given the recent scandals at Merrill Lynch and AIG, some analysts are gleefully rubbing their hands together as they prepare to feast on Wagoner's bones. After all, his outsize pension makes the former CEO seem like the kind of bloated, self-important business executive who has led America into economic disarray. Beyond that, outrage at executive compensation is pretty much the order of the day, and Wagoner is a big, fat, $23 million target. But does he deserve the many arrows of righteous indignation being shot his way?
It is worth noting, in Wagoner's defense: he has not received a penny of severance pay, nor will he. His pension, large as it is, cannot reasonably be compared with the work-for-18-months-collect-$10-million packages that so liberally litter Wall Street (and have drained so many companies' coffers). First off, Wagoner will not receive that money in a lump sum: rather, he will continue to get monthly payments for the rest of his life. Second, he has been paying into this pension for the last three decades; he did not receive it as a gift from GM's board of directors, nor is it some sort of executive payoff or non-competition agreement, as was the case in many of the recent scandals.
While Wagoner's pension seems huge, it says a lot more about GM's traditional attitudes toward employee compensation than it does about the business climate of the past few years. GM has a history of overpaying its employees; this, in fact, has been cited as one of Wagoner's basic problems during his tenure in charge of the company. After restructuring retirement programs in 2006 and cutting workforce and benefits in 2008, Wagoner affirmed earlier this year that the car maker would not cut retiree benefits.
As Wagoner rides off into the sunset, many point out that his ouster seems to be a largely symbolic gesture, as his successor, Fritz Henderson, was already the heir apparent and is expected to follow the same policies as Wagoner. Still, it sends a strong message that CEOs who repeatedly ask for government bailouts may ultimately be asked to fall on their swords.
Of course, sometimes those swords are beautifully gilded ...
Given the recent scandals at Merrill Lynch and AIG, some analysts are gleefully rubbing their hands together as they prepare to feast on Wagoner's bones. After all, his outsize pension makes the former CEO seem like the kind of bloated, self-important business executive who has led America into economic disarray. Beyond that, outrage at executive compensation is pretty much the order of the day, and Wagoner is a big, fat, $23 million target. But does he deserve the many arrows of righteous indignation being shot his way?
It is worth noting, in Wagoner's defense: he has not received a penny of severance pay, nor will he. His pension, large as it is, cannot reasonably be compared with the work-for-18-months-collect-$10-million packages that so liberally litter Wall Street (and have drained so many companies' coffers). First off, Wagoner will not receive that money in a lump sum: rather, he will continue to get monthly payments for the rest of his life. Second, he has been paying into this pension for the last three decades; he did not receive it as a gift from GM's board of directors, nor is it some sort of executive payoff or non-competition agreement, as was the case in many of the recent scandals.
While Wagoner's pension seems huge, it says a lot more about GM's traditional attitudes toward employee compensation than it does about the business climate of the past few years. GM has a history of overpaying its employees; this, in fact, has been cited as one of Wagoner's basic problems during his tenure in charge of the company. After restructuring retirement programs in 2006 and cutting workforce and benefits in 2008, Wagoner affirmed earlier this year that the car maker would not cut retiree benefits.
As Wagoner rides off into the sunset, many point out that his ouster seems to be a largely symbolic gesture, as his successor, Fritz Henderson, was already the heir apparent and is expected to follow the same policies as Wagoner. Still, it sends a strong message that CEOs who repeatedly ask for government bailouts may ultimately be asked to fall on their swords.
Of course, sometimes those swords are beautifully gilded ...



























Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
3-31-2009 @ 10:23AM
Donovan said...
Wagoner should feel blessed. Doesn't need to deal with the GM financial mess anymore. Plus a 23 million dollar pension, that's what I call one sweet deal.
Resign/Retire/Fired, who cares what its called. As long as it comes with a few million dollars, when you walk out the door.
Reply
3-31-2009 @ 5:08PM
Jeff said...
Really now, read the article. It's a pension. He's been paying into this in part out of his own pocket for over thirty years. If you're going to remark snidely about CEOs collecting their pensions, why not go after everyone else collecting a pension? Start with yourself.
5-29-2009 @ 6:30PM
Doug said...
Hay JEFF,
Chill out ....
Reply
5-29-2009 @ 11:58PM
KJM said...
Only $23,000,000? Only? So what if he contributed some? The overwhelming majority of human beings dont make 20% of that amount in an entire lifetime! And how many of them lead one of the country's most important and largest companies into bankruptcy while maintaining a disgusting arrogance?!
Reply
5-30-2009 @ 9:38AM
Brandon said...
Well now, the way I see it.. He walked away with a bag of money either way you phrase it. I retired on April 1st and didn't get $23,000000000000000000.00 Gazilion Dollars I get $?,???.?? a month, I live pretty good, even though my mortgage has " Flipped " and my mortgage co.( Bank of America, formally Countrywide ) is NOT willing to help me get a lower payment. I worked at GM for 30+years and now sense Wagoner SCREWED up the company :( Kinda like Bush Jackin up OUR country!:( I have to wait and see what else the company will take away. Am I angry? NAW!
Reply