Pull-ups are twice as expensive as diapers. Each not-on-the-potty experience costs me a whopping 40 cents. Diapers run 20 cents a pop. We go through four or five of these a day, despite the fact that potty training is going pretty well. The costs add up pretty quickly on the monthly budget. My daughter thinks I'm anxious to get her trained so that she can be a big girl, but really it's all about dollars. The longer she goes in diapers, the more I have to pay.
I don't know why pull-ups are so much more expensive, except for the fact that you are supposed to use fewer of them so parents are duped into shelling out a higher price. They come in smaller packs (typically 44 or so rather than 100-plus) and you use them for a shorter span of time (typically a few months rather than 2-plus years). But other than that, they are not any more or less absorbant and they don't make it any easier for a child to run and play.
Kids did just fine potty training before the mass marketing of these pseudo-diapers, either just going straight to underwear or going with an underwear/plastic cover combo. I'm thinking it was even easier then, because kids learned cold turkey, with none of this half-measure stuff that just confuses them. One weekend of cleaning up accidents and that's that. Or else, just go back to diapers for a little while and try again later.
But pull-ups are pushed on unsuspecting parents mercilessly now. It's not just advertising, but also childcare providers and potty training guides. Pull-ups have become just another step in the process and you're somehow deficient if you skip this step. Of all the conventions about child rearing that have changed over the years, this is the one I am going to rebel against.
I am declaring my shopping cart free of Disney princess pull-ups. No Dora the Explorer Cool Alert. No knock-off brands either. It's diapers or nothing for my little trainee.
We'll see how long this resolution lasts. . .